I will start off by saying that I am not in love with this product, but I do not dislike it. After looking at all of the palettes, I went with Moonlit. The pigmentation is so-so and there is a good deal of shimmer. However, I just swatched these about 10 min ago and I already notice a reduction in pigment and shimmer. So you definitley need to wear a primer with these. I wore this palette to class a few days ago with primer(Stila's Prime Pot) and they did last all day with minor reduction in color. The number one thing I dislike about this product is the feel of the shadow. It is not soft and smooth but powdery and somewhat gritty(especially the top two shades). The bottom two perform better for me as they are a little more smooth and easier to work with. The pigmentation is also a little bit better. I would rate this a 3.5 out of 5. It is not my favorite product, but it works well enough for me to keep using it.
