Culture Magazine

Review: Jane Eyre (Lifeline Theatre)

By Chicagotheaterbeat @chitheaterbeat

Review: Jane Eyre (Lifeline Theatre)   
Jane Eyre

Adapted by Christina Calvit
From the novel by Charlotte Brontë  
Directed by Dorothy Milne
at Lifeline Theatre, 6912 N. Glenwood (map)
thru Oct 26 Nov 16  |  tickets: $40   |  more info
Check for half-price tickets 
   Read review

Now extended thru November 16th!


Despite dramatic design, fiery love story rather tepid affair


Review: Jane Eyre (Lifeline Theatre)


Lifeline Theatre presents


Jane Eyre

Review by Catey Sullivan 

With Kevin D. Gawley’s dramatically shadowy lighting, Christopher Kriz’ ominous, spikey sound design, William Boles’ angular, disquieting set, Lifeline’s Jane Eyre captures the wondrously Gothic atmosphere Charlotte Brontë’s 1847 proto-feminist thriller/romance. Directed by Dorothy Milne, this is a show that looks and sounds marvelous, from the startling, eerie sonic backdrop to the physical evocation of utter ruin that marks the story’s climactic resolution.

Review: Jane Eyre (Lifeline Theatre)
But in Christina Calvit’s adaptation of Bronte’s novel, the story within those design elements gets short shrift. If you’re not already well familiar with Jane Eyre’s narrative you may well find yourself puzzled. Key characters who play essential roles in the book show up with little in the way of context or character development in Calvit’s telling. Crucial events in Jane’s life are glossed over so lightly they’re rendered unimportant and almost indiscernible. As for the overwhelmingly passionate love story that brings both joy and tragedy into Jane’s life, it’s a somewhat tepid affair.

The bulk of Bronte’s tale of a governess who falls in love with her mysterious employer takes place at Thornfield Hall, the gloomy, looming mansion that’s home to the handsome, broody Edward Rochester (John Henry Roberts). It’s there that Jane (Anu Bhatt) falls in love and proves herself to be a woman of iron will and utterly uncompromising ideals. Totally, overwhelmingly and irrevocably in love, Jane nevertheless refuses to let that love alter her determination to live life on her own terms, in control of her own destiny and the lesser of no man.

But Bronte also devotes a significant chunk of the novel to Jane’s pre-governess life, and these early, important chapters barely register in Calvit’s adaptation.

As a 10-year-old orphan enduring endless torments as an unwanted child in the home of her Aunt Sarah Reed (Kyra Morris) and her sadistic, spoiled cousin John, Jane’s childhood reaches the heights of horror and crimson-vivid symbolism with her terrifying exile to the dreaded “Red Room.”  It’s a scene that wouldn’t be out of place in a Stephen King novel. It’s also one that can be interpreted as a fascinating commentary on the fear and revulsion generated by nascent female sexuality. The segment is a complex mile-marker in the novel, both in terms of plot development and subtext. On Lifeline’s stage, it’s reduced to little more than a few seconds of wailing.

From the comfortless confines of the Reeds, young Jane is sent to an equally abusive children’s home where she’s targeted and tormented by cruel teachers who hold her up as an example of evil to be shunned at all costs. It’s there that Jane meets the saintly Helen (Maya Lou Hlava), a tragic, beatific young girl who teaches Jane the value of forgiveness and kindness, even in the face of unadulterated viciousness. The angelic Helen isn’t around for long, but like the Red Room, she’s critical in the formation of Jane’s character.

Helen shows up throughout Calvit’s adaptation, but she’s little more than a stock figure from a clichéd ghost story, a wraithlike urchin in a bloody nightgown, uttering repetitive warnings about the danger of caring too much about what others think of you. We never learn who she is, what her relationship to Jane is, or why she’s so firmly lodged in Jane’s psyche.

Calvit doesn’t start really digging into the story until Jane arrives at Thornfield.  Some 167 years after Jane Eyre’s publication, it seems fair to assume that revealing the secret shut up in a darkened corner of Thornfield no longer counts as a spoiler. Once Rochester falls in love with Jane, we learn that there’s another woman in his life: Bertha is an almost feral figure whose primal and literally fiery rages are the polar opposite of the chilly flirtations displayed by the beribboned and feathered society ladies Rochester entertains and the self-controlled, steely resolve of Jane.

Rochester’s treatment of Bertha (a wild-eyed Jhenai Mootz) might have been somewhat understandable in the 19th-century. One of the challenges in staging Jane Eyre lies in the fact that today, Rochester’s behavior toward the unfortunate Bertha is downright criminal, not to mention indescribably appalling. Calvit has a tough job in ensuring Rochester doesn’t turn into a one-dimensionally despicable villain once Bertha’s on the scene, and she doesn’t quite succeed.

As the moody Lord of the Manor, Roberts – who reads as far too young for the role – succeeds in capturing the tortured soul of the man, but not in generating much empathy for him. The lack of chemistry between Bhatt and Roberts doesn’t help matters. Jane and Rochester’s  all-consuming ardor never rings true. When they first fall in love, it seems to come out of left field. When they finally swear their devotion to each other, their declarations seem studied.

Minus that chemistry and so much of the early essence in Bronte’s book, “Jane Eyre” never really takes flight. The story is missing both Jane’s raw, beating, authentic heart and the gloriously undiminished empowerment she finds under the most oppressive circumstances.


Rating: ★★½



Jane Eyre continues through October 26th November 16th at Lifeline Theatre, 6912 N. Glenwood (map), with performances Thursdays and Fridays at 7:30pm, Saturdays 4pm and 8pm, Sundays 4pm.  Tickets are $40 ($30 for seniors, students $20), and are available by phone (773-761-4477) or online through (check for half-price tickets at More info at time: 2 hours 15 minutes, includes an intermission)

Photos by Suzanne Plunkett 




Heather Currie (Mrs. Fairfax, Lady Ingram, Hannah), Anu Bhatt (Jane Eyre), LaNisa Frederick (Grace Poole, Amy Eshton, Mary Rivers), Ada Grey (Adele), Maya Lou Hlava (Helen), Anthony Kayer (Brocklehurst, Dr. Carter, Rev. Wood, Porter), Jhenai Mootz (Bertha, Blanche), Kyra Morris (Mrs. Reed, Mary Ingram, Diana Rivers), Joshua Moaney (Richard Mason, St. John Rivers), John Henry Roberts (Edward Rochester), Galya Loeb, Kate McDermott, Michael Woods (understudies).

behind the scenes

Dorothy Milne (director), Kevin D. Gawley (lighting and projection design), Jana Anderson (costume design), Becky Bishop (stage manager), William Boles (set design), Kitty Campbell (properties design), Benjamin W. Dawson (production manager), Jordan Kardasz (assistant lighting and projection design), John Kelly (master electrician), Jason Kirk Martin (dialect coach), Autumn McConnico (dramaturg), Christopher Kriz (original music, sound design), Kate Reed (assistant stage manager), Browyn Sherman (assistant director), Joe Schermoly (technical director), Sarah Fornace (fight and movement director), Suzanne Plunkett (photos)


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Carolina Strong & Have You Marked Yourself Safe?

    Carolina Strong Have Marked Yourself Safe?

    Still getting through Hurricane Florence here in the Carolinas. While I live in central NC, we have had our share of flooding, trees down, power outages and yes... Read more

    The 18 September 2018 by   Midlifemargaritas
  • Questions to Be Asked About Discussion of Sexual Abuse: Why Is Abuse of...

    Questions Asked About Discussion Sexual Abuse: Abuse Vulnerable Females Adult Males Shrugged Easily?

    Speaking from the vantage point of a "but half-woke" straight male, David Roberts writes, Sexual discrimination, harassment, and abuse are everywhere. Read more

    The 18 September 2018 by   William Lindsey
  • What to Do Instead of Counting Calories?

    A while ago, Dr. Andreas Eenfeldt met Dr. Jason Fung to discuss calorie counting. Is it the best way to lose weight or is it more complicated than the theory... Read more

    The 18 September 2018 by   Dietdoctor
  • Boeing 787-9 Dreamliner

    Boeing 787-9 Dreamliner

    @ San Francisco, CA June 2018 A Virgin Atlantic Dreamliner on final approach for landing at SFO.  Virgin operates 17 Dreamliners in their current fleet,... Read more

    The 18 September 2018 by   Htam
  • On Waiting…


    We are sitting in a government office in Suleimaniyah (commonly called Suli) and we are waiting. We left Rania at seven in the morning. The sun had already... Read more

    The 18 September 2018 by   Marilyngardner5
  • Is Low-carb the Best Treatment for Reversing Diabetes?

    Low-carb Best Treatment Reversing Diabetes?

    The diabetes diet debate has shifted, and the result could save millions of people. The question used to be, is a low-carb high-fat diet dangerous? Is it going... Read more

    The 18 September 2018 by   Dietdoctor
  • London Design Festival 2018 - Interesting New Designs

    London Design Festival 2018 Interesting Designs

    15 - 23 September 2018 chair ‘Iklwa’, design Mac Collins at 100% design Leading bathroom brand VitrA participates for the first time in designjunction,one of th... Read more

    The 18 September 2018 by   Trendoffice