Etude House Sweet Recipe Chocolate Smudge Liner

Hi everyone!
Today I'm going to review Etude House New Eyeliner! It's from the famous new line "Sweet Recipe" called "Sweet Recipe - Chocolate Smudge Liner".
This line being soooo famous out there, since Etude House has made their packaging so damn cute.
The Sweet Recipe line was inspired by fairy tale story "Hansel and Gretel".
Well, let's go on!

It comes with a delicious looks of dark chocolate!! Can't you imagine how cute it is?? I do cannot resist any cute packaging like this >_<

It's a gel eyeliner, but unfortunately it doesn't come with any eyeliner brush! So, we would spend more money to buy the brush separately. Nice idea to collect more money, huh? LOL.
It comes with 2 colours to be chosen, Milk Chocolate and Dark Chocolate. Mine is the dark one.
Let's take some swatches!

1. It makes a bold color of chocolate, the pigmentation is quite good. 2. Waterproof? YES! The color stays strong while I pour water on it.3. Smudgeproof? Of course NOT! LOL. As we know, it's named 'smudge liner'4. Hard to be cleaned, i think you'll need more eye remover to clean it up.
And these are how it looks on my eyes ^O^Picture spam alert!! LOL.1. My bare eyes, i was wearing Geo Lens from Tomato Shop (review here). 2. Clean line, I applied it with my Masami Shouko Gel Liner Brush.3. And this is how it looks after i smudged it.
1. Clear Line2. Smudged Line
My FOTD while wearing this Sweet Recipe Chocolate Smudge Eyeliner. Is that good enough compared to its uber cute packaging? I prefer a clear line on my eyes rather than a smudged one, honestly.How was it ladies?? Have you ever tried this? Share them below!
That's all i wanna share about ^^
Thanks fpr visiting and reading my blog, hope you find it useful.
Lotta love,
Yessy.