I’m rather proud of this idea that came by chance today. I’ve been experimenting with a black foam pumpkin Michaels recently gave me, and then a parent donated a ton of colored tape. Voila! A mosaic pumpkin that was easy to make and has a cool graphic look.
I used a brand of orange painters tape called “Shurtape”. It's made to stick really well, and has a nice glossy look to it. Cut up little pieces of tape that are irregular in shape and size and place on pumpkin so that they look like puzzle pieces fitting together. Smooth the edges often so they lie flat. Happy Halloween!