Problem was my container was an old shampoo bottle. Not a big deal, I love to recycle, but the existing label wasn't a sticker and I couldn't get the print off. Since I like to have a label on things (as to not confuse anyone in the house), I had to make a label that wasn't going to smear and rub off.
I printed my own label on sticker paper and pulled out some self adhesive vinyl protector I had on hand.
I sized the vinyl a little larger than the sticker than stuck them both on my bottle.
Yay! New label and new makeup remover. By the way, give your mixture a good shake before using since the ingredients like to separate.
And if you want to make some, too, here's the label for your own bottle. Just right click and save and you can resize it to fit your own container.