Biology Magazine

Could Neanderthals Speak? Implications of FOXP2

Posted on the 25 September 2018 by Reprieve @EvoAnth

FOXP2 is one of the most famous genes out there; notable for containing two mutations linked to language in humans. These mutations are also in Neanderthals, which is strong evidence they could speak like us 1.

However, it turns the importance of FOXP2 may have been overblown, despite the fact we've been studying it for more than 20 years. A recent study looking at the gene in more than a thousand people failed to find the purported link to language evolution 2.

As well as changing our understanding of language evolution, this also has implications for speech in ancient human species. Can we still be confident Neanderthals could talk like us? What other evidence is there?

FOXP2 failure

The FOXP2 gene was one of the first to be linked to language, way back in the early 2000s. People with mutations that broke this gene had problems with language, cementing a link between the two.

The mere existence of a link is interesting, but not the most important thing about our version of FOXP2. It turns out that our version of the gene had been evolving relatively recently. Specifically, positive selection appears to have spread the human mutations throughout our species ~200,000 years ago. This spread suggests that (a) these mutations were really helpful for our survival and (b) gave us a unique ability. Does that sound like language to anyone else 1?

Around a decade later we found that Neanderthals and Denisovans had the same mutations in FOXP2. Surely this meant they also had language!

However, some researchers became skeptical. How could FOXP2 be present in Neanderthals, who split from us more than half a million years ago, and us if it only evolved recently? Clearly, something was amiss.

So now, nearly 20 years after it was first discovered, researchers have returned to FOXP2. This time, they looked at the gene in the hundreds of human genomes we've sequenced in the intervening years. This huge sample revealed that the evidence of positive selection for FOXP2 just wasn't there.

So it's back to the genetic drawing board for explaining language.

Neanderthal noises

It's taken decades, but Neanderthals are slowly recovering from their Victorian-era reputation as savage brutes. Does this discovery undo any of this?

Fortunately for the Neanderthals' PR team, there are still plenty of other indicators they had language like us.

For instance, the shape of your ear bones influences what sounds you can hear. Unlike other primates, our bones are great at hearing noises at 1-6 kHz, which just so happens to be the range speech falls in. Neanderthals also fall in this range, meaning they could hear speech-like noises 3.

They could also probably make these noises too. The hyoid bone in your neck is the source of many mouth muscles we use in speech. Thus, its shape has a big influence on the noises we make. And, you guessed it, Neanderthals had a hyoid a lot like ours.

As well as helping them make some noises, this bone also indicates they had lost other noise making capability as well. Some species have air sacs around their hyoid that help them make loud noises. Humans (and Neanderthals) have lost this ability, in exchange for being able to make clearer sounds3.

Of course, language is more than just hearing and making certain noises. Otherwise, there'd be more than one band fronted by a parrot. So is there any indication Neanderthals were actually using their noises for language?

What about language?

Clearer evidence of language is harder to come by, given Neanderthals never had the decency to write anything down. Nevertheless, there are some who say that their culture is so complex that they must have had some language capacity. Particularly to pass it on from generation to generation. It certainly is quite hard to teach someone by just going "ooga ooga"2.

Notably, many aspects of Neanderthal technology were on par with contemporary Homo sapiens. We both made similar tools that required extensive forethought and planning, including specialised inventions for specific roles. We also both created a variety of artistic artefacts, ranging from jewellery to cave art2.

So if we want to argue that our species had language back then, it follows we must also conclude Neanderthals were a chatty bunch too.

So, even without FOXP2 there's good reason to think Neanderthals were talkative. Which means I've just waffled on for a thousand words to essentially say "nothings changed to see here".

Hopefully, you still found it interesting.

References

  1. Dediu, D. and Levinson, S.C., 2018. Neanderthal language revisited: not only us. Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences, 21, pp.49-55. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cobeha.2018.01.001
  2. Atkinson, E.G., Audesse, A.J., Palacios, J.A., Bobo, D.M., Webb, A.E., Ramachandran, S. and Henn, B.M., 2018. No Evidence for Recent Selection at FOXP2 among Diverse Human Populations. Cell. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2018.06.048
  3. Dediu, D. and Levinson, S.C., 2013. On the antiquity of language: the reinterpretation of Neandertal linguistic capacities and its consequences. Frontiers in psychology, 4, p.397.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Opera Review: Going For the Throat

    Opera Review: Going Throat

    Stuart Skelton debuts in Otello. by Paul J. Pelkonen There's been a nasty cold rampaging around New York this month. It struck down your faithful correspondent... Read more

    The 18 December 2018 by   Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
  • Celebrating Sisters with Sisters Wine

    Celebrating Sisters with Wine

    Tis the season for celebration and being with friends and family. To celebrate each other, our relationships and look to a new year.Sisters come in all forms. Read more

    The 18 December 2018 by   Hvwinegoddess
    DRINK, FOOD & DRINK
  • From Phantom Limbs to Charlie Chaplin: Marianne Simmel Papers Open for Research

    From Phantom Limbs Charlie Chaplin: Marianne Simmel Papers Open Research

    contributed by Allan Christopher, Amanda Leach, Sarah Riddle, M. Rose Stull (students in the Museums Archives Certificate Program). Read more

    The 18 December 2018 by   Chp
    HEALTH, HISTORY, PSYCHOLOGY
  • Above the Clouds: Two Sunsets

    Above Clouds: Sunsets

    An amazing sunset taken some 35,000 feet above the earth Read more

    The 18 December 2018 by   Travellingartist
    TRAVEL
  • December 19th - Freebies!

    December 19th Freebies!

    December 19th is... Believe It or Not Day (1918), National Oatmeal Muffin Day, Can't Get Up Day (1985), Space Milestone: First Radio Broadcast from Space (1958)... Read more

    The 18 December 2018 by   Catherine Mcdiarmid-Watt
    FAMILY, FINANCE, SHOPPING
  • From the Rock to the Sandbar

    From Rock Sandbar

    Early morning here as I write this. I'm sipping coffee before getting ready for work, and watching a fox snoop around the property. Read more

    The 18 December 2018 by   Seliharris
    SOCIETY
  • Diet Doctor Podcast #9 — Dr. Ron Krauss

    And he's the director of atherosclerosis research at the Children's Hospital Oakland research Institute, he's a professor of medicine at UCSF, professor of... Read more

    The 18 December 2018 by   Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE

Magazines