Current Magazine

APA Moves to Redefine Autism

By Periscope @periscopepost

As APA moves to redefine autism, questions over whether it and Asperger are over-diagnosed

Warren Buffett is thought by some to have an autism disroder, possibly Asperger. Photo credit: Wikipedia commons

The American Psychiatric Association is currently putting the finishing touches on the fifth edition of its Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, better known as the DSM and even better known as the psychiatric community’s Bible. Among the changes the Association is considering is a narrowed redefinition of what constitutes autism, especially as diagnoses of autism and Asperger syndrome, a disorder on the autism spectrum, skyrocket.

But, as The New York Times reported last week, that has some experts worried that changing that definition would make it more difficult for people suffering from autism to get the care they need. At the same time, some claim that a narrowed definition of what autism is will eliminate some of the vagueness around autism diagnoses and ensure that those who are told they have the disorder actually have it. A new debate is emerging: Is autism over-diagnosed?

Asperger is over-diagnosed. Asperger syndrome, a disorder characterized by difficulties in social interactions, is coming in for particular questioning as it tends to be on the higher functioning end of the autism scale. Paul Steinberg, a psychiatrist, wrote in an op-ed for The New York Times, noted that the syndrome has long been a popular and often incorrect diagnosis for children and adults who are just a bit quirky. “The downside to this diagnosis lies in evidence that children with social disabilities, diagnosed now with an autism-spectrum disorder like Asperger, have lower self-esteem and poorer social development when inappropriately placed in school environments with truly autistic children,” he wrote, adding too that adults can be denied opportunities for work based on this incorrect diagnosis. “We can only hope that better physiological markers distinguishing between the autism-spectrum disorders and pure social disabilities can stem this tide of ever more pathologizing.”

I had Asperger – briefly. Also in The New York Times (it’s Asperger day over there), writer Benjamin Nugent explained in an op-ed how he was diagnosed with Asperger as a young adult because he had few friends and spent most of his time reading, writing poetry, and playing the guitar. But he grew out of it. “The biggest single problem with the diagnostic criteria applied to me is this: You can be highly perceptive with regard to social interaction, as a child or adolescent, and still be a spectacular social failure. This is particularly true if you’re bad at sports or nervous or weird-looking.” Nugent welcomed the upcoming change to the DSM, noting, “Under the rules in place today, any nerd, any withdrawn, bookish kid, can have Asperger syndrome.”

No biological test. Jacob Sullum, writing at Reason, highlighted Nugent’s piece, but noted that just because he doesn’t now have Asperger doesn’t exactly mean he never had it, being as he met the previous DSM criteria. “As with drawing a line between normal grief and ‘major depression,’ there is no biological test that can verify the diagnosis. It is all a matter of how psychiatrists choose to label (or not label) certain patterns of behavior, which nevertheless can have a serious impact how people perceive themselves and live their lives.”

Calling BS on ‘over-diagnosis’ claim. Joslyn Gray, a mother of an son with Asperger at Babble’s Strollerderby blog, called shenanigans on the claim that Asperger is over-diagnosed: “Everyone who thinks that the autism or Asperger diagnosis is being handed out like candy can suck it, suck it, suck it. Because I am 100 percent sure anyone who says that has never tried to get a child evaluated, diagnosed, and treated for something like autism. It takes months, people. Months and sometimes years. And paperwork. And appointment, after appointment, after appointment.” An autism diagnosis is serious business; ignoring autism, she wrote, won’t make it go away.

DSM redefinition will have serious impact on families. For families with children who at some point go off the rails of normal child development, the DSM’s new definition of autism is problematic, wrote Laura McKenna at The Atlantic, parent of a child diagnosed with autism. Her son, Ian, was diagnosed with autism after wandering lost “through the forest of disability labels” for three years; but after his diagnosis, he was able to get the treatment he needed. Narrowing the definition of autism will exclude children with real problems. “For those of us whose lives are inextricable from the politics of autism, it is the label — the one that was so difficult for us to accept at first — that has been the key to getting help for our children.”

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • How Candice Got Her Life Back

    Candice had always been fit and active. Then all of a sudden, she started gaining weight. After having two kids, she was at her all-time high and was always... Read more

    The 15 December 2018 by   Dietdoctor
  • FIDLAR at 102.1 The Edge – Sugar Beach Sessions

    FIDLAR 102.1 Edge Sugar Beach Sessions

    On a surprisingly warm December day, FIDLAR stopped by the 102.1 Edge studios for a Sugar Beach Session. FIDLAR is a four-piece punk rock band from Los... Read more

    The 15 December 2018 by   Phjoshua
  • The Mortal Engines Has a Stupid Premise. That Doesn’t Mean It’s a Stupid Movie.

    Mortal Engines Stupid Premise. That Doesn’t Mean It’s Movie.

    We keep saying we want Hollywood to get better and pull back on all the reboots, revival, sequels, and general retelling of old stories. Why not try to tell... Read more

    The 15 December 2018 by
  • Saturday 15th December: Annie Keene

    Saturday 15th December: Annie Keene

    Only ten days to Christmas and only nine Blogvents left and so let's crack on with our lady of the day and she will be a very familiar face to all Cameron... Read more

    The 15 December 2018 by   Kirsty Stonell Walker
  • “Will I Get Angry Easily If I Skip Carbs?”

    “Will Angry Easily Skip Carbs?”

    How many carbs should I aim for per day to remain weight stable? How can I stop myself from overeating? These and other questions are answered this week by... Read more

    The 15 December 2018 by   Dietdoctor
  • Franchise Weekend – The Nutty Professor (1996)

    Franchise Weekend Nutty Professor (1996)

    Director: Tom Shadyac Writer: David Sheffield, Barry W Blaustein, Tom Shadyac, Steve Oedekerk (Screenplay) Jerry Lewis, Bill Richmond (Original Screenplay)... Read more

    The 15 December 2018 by   Newguy
  • Vans RV-7

    Vans RV-7

    @ Chino Airport, CA May 2018 This RV-7 sits waiting for a pilot to hop in and take her up.  The Van’s RV-7 is a two-seat, single-engine, low-wing homebuilt... Read more

    The 15 December 2018 by   Htam