Pottery Barn Knock Off Lamps

When I was looking around the other day to find a few items for our home projects, I ran across some lamps at Target that I completely love.  Pottery barn sells a similar styled lamp that I have always had my eye on, but not my wallet.  I just thought if I could find something similar to them for a lesser price then they would fit perfectly with my décor.   Here is the one from Pottery Barn for $169 (no longer available)...   Here are the ones I purchased for  $60 each...        A little bit more bubbly of a cage bottom, but it kinda reminds me of when I was little and I would push bubbles through the tray thingy!   Do you like the look of the more bubbly based ones that I was able to snag for less than half the price of the Pottery Barn ones?   I think it goes so much better with the style of our home than the silver ones I had there before.