Psychology Magazine

Norm Enforcement is Biased from Its Emergence.

By Deric Bownds @DericBownds

Interesting work from Jordan et al. on the appearance of in-group bias in punishing selfish behaviors in insiders versus outsiders:

When enforcing norms for cooperative behavior, human adults sometimes exhibit in-group bias. For example, third-party observers punish selfish behaviors committed by out-group members more harshly than similar behaviors committed by in-group members. Although evidence suggests that children begin to systematically punish selfish behavior around the age of 6 y, the development of in-group bias in their punishment remains unknown. Do children start off enforcing fairness norms impartially, or is norm enforcement biased from its emergence? How does bias change over development? Here, we created novel social groups in the laboratory and gave 6- and 8-year-olds the opportunity to engage in costly third-party punishment of selfish sharing behavior. We found that by age 6, punishment was already biased: Selfish resource allocations received more punishment when they were proposed by out-group members and when they disadvantaged in-group members. We also found that although costly punishment increased between ages 6 and 8, bias in punishment partially decreased. Although 8-y-olds also punished selfish out-group members more harshly, they were equally likely to punish on behalf of disadvantaged in-group and out-group members, perhaps reflecting efforts to enforce norms impartially. Taken together, our results suggest that norm enforcement is biased from its emergence, but that this bias can be partially overcome through developmental change.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Country Chic Photoshoot

    Country Chic Photoshoot

    Today’s styled shoot will mesmerize you with its unique country chic style! The barn of the Marathon equestrian center was the ideal background for natural,... Read more

    13 hours, 44 minutes ago by   Eleni Balkouli
  • TokyoTreat Unboxing: Japanese Candy Dreams Come True

    TokyoTreat Unboxing: Japanese Candy Dreams Come True

    TokyoTreat recently reached out to me to check out their amazing subscription boxes, full to the brim of delicious Japanese candy and snacks! Read more

    14 hours, 43 minutes ago by   Cubiclethrowdown
  • To Abby, With Love

    Abby, With Love

    Glennon, I realize Abby is all yours.  I got a pretty fantastic feminist husband of my own.  However, your wife turned a corner for me I never thought I’d get... Read more

    16 hours, 51 minutes ago by   Amanda Bruce
  • Extra Flavoursome Red Wine Beef Stew with Bacon

    Extra Flavoursome Wine Beef Stew with Bacon

    version;"Your beef stew got standard! Must cook again!"After I have cooked this EASY healthy red wine beef stew at here for my family, my beef-loving husband an... Read more

    17 hours, 29 minutes ago by   Zoebakeforhappykids
  • Neck Bone Recipe

    Neck Bone Recipe

    I posted on my face book page that I was making my mom neck bone this weekend and I had several requests for the recipe - so, I decided to make a post of it. ... Read more

    The 15 July 2018 by   Kalamitykelli
  • Sensitive Skin Saviours: What I Do When My Skin is Super Sensitive

    Sensitive Skin Saviours: What When Super

    At least twice a year my skin freaks out, gets really sensitive, red, dry and flaky. Most products sting and it's very uncomfortable. It's only happened since w... Read more

    The 15 July 2018 by   Glossqueen
  • Building A Team Around Your Band

    So I just watched my nations team, the French team, win the world cup, and it was glorious. It got me thinking quite a bit about teamwork though and I wanted... Read more

    The 15 July 2018 by   Indiemusicpromo