Science Magazine

Into Everlasting Fire.... The Economist December Holiday Issue

Posted on the 21 February 2013 by Jkinyoun @jkinyoun
During my long break from this blog I've been catching up on personal and professional matters of all sorts- cleaning my house, updating my baby gear to toddler gear, preparing my slides/materials for another semester of introductory chemistry, and of course reading my backlog of Economist weekly publications gathering dust on my bookshelf.
Recently my issues of Wall Street Journal and The Economist have been shelved more than I'd like to admit.... however today I dug out my double-holiday issue from December and digested the article on hell.
Hell isn't something I've really thought about much. I do attend a Christian church and study the Bible. In fact, I just finished  Bart D. Ehrman's (James A. Gray Distinguished Professor of Religious Studies at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill)   series of lectures about the New Testament (on CD). Notably, there is almost no mention of hell in this series of lectures which leads me to believe the New Testament really does not include a description of hell or a detailed picture of what hell is like.  In contrast, Amy-Jill Levine (E. Rhodes and Leona B. Carpenter Professor of New Testament Studies at Vanderbilt University Divinity School) does mention damnation in her lectures on the Old Testment within the context of Old Testment stories like the destruction of Soddom and Gommorah; but a description of hell as an afterlife is noticeably left out of the Old Testament as well.
This article in The Economist focuses on a broad range of illustrations throughout history, both religious and secular, about how hell can be grasped by humans- with some abstract intellectual ability but  who largely exist in a corporeal state.
Here are some descriptions of hell from various sources that jumped out at me:
"It is a torture-place for the damned in which they are flayed or eaten alive, disembowelled or impaled on stakes, either for incalcuable ages or actually forever." -author of article (unlisted)
"[Christian hell] an inverted funnel of several layers separated by rocky banks, with each layer deeper and narrower than the last."   - Dante
Buddhist hell: Similar to Christian hell but with many mansions....Hinduism has 21 main Hells and a lakh of smaller ones   -author article
The scientific inaccuracies about hell are numerous: This article points out that the fire of hell needs no fuel nor does it consume what it burns. So- the law of conservation of mass and the law of conservation of energy are defied in a conventional understanding of hell. (Try throwing special relativity and quantum mechanics into that mess- ha!) My students' confusion about the transfer of heat from hot to cold and the equality of heat transferred from one object and received by another colder object also become a mute point. The concept of eternal cold seems to exist simultaneously with the eternal fire- this grossly defies the rules of heat transfer as well.... "The devisers of Hell also realized, however, that continual scalding heat could become routine; so deep snow and ice alternated with the fire."
Hell seems to have no sense of time as well. (Perhaps special relativity relates here more than previously thought.) "Buddhist teachers asked their pupils to imagine a cart loaded with 20 kharis of sesame seed, from which once every century one tiny seed was removed; yet when the whole cartload had gone, they would still be in the first Hell, and thousands of further Hells lay beyond it."
Then we have the concept of light vs dark. Hell's fires mean that it is never completely dark, yet it isn't supposed to be light either. "No light, but rather darkness visible," wrote Milton.
What happens to the body in hell? The body is left behind- pain can no longer touch it. Yet hell seems to imply that there is eternal pain to a vulnerable soul of some sort.
Many more modern descriptions of hell paint a more psychological picture of something beyond human grasp:
Hell means ceasing to hope. - St. Thomas Aquinas
"Hell is the being shut up in the possession of corporeal desires." William Blake
Perhaps the real reason for an understanding of hell is an appreciation for the kingdom of the righteous, or heaven:
"Knowledge of the torments of the damned is part of heavenly bliss." -St. Augustine
There can be no sweetness in heaven  "if there were no infernal descant from God's justice." - St. Vernardino of Siena
The author concludes with a powerful statement that I quote here:\
"Just as there can be no light without dark, and no sound without silence, so everlasting celestial joys depend on a contrast or everlasting horror. Without Hell, you can't have Heaven."

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog