Creativity Magazine

Alas, I Failed To Win The Big New York Comic Con Poster Contest

By Mrstrongest @mrstrongarm

I entered a poster design contest last fall. Alas, I didn’t win. Years ago, I would have labeled this a failure. Now I’m smarter: I call it a “learning experience.”  : )

Here’s my losing entry:

Poster design for RedBubble contest for New York Comic Con comics and pop culture convention masked worm superhero emerging from apple representing Big Apple and blowing soap bubbles

It’s the sort of thing that begs an explanation, isn’t it??

I’ll start by telling you that Redbubble is an online store for artists and illustrators. I have a Redbubble account, but I’ve been using Fine Art America to sell my work. There are many such online stores. They handle the printing, framing, and mailing, and they take the lion’s share of the sale price.

The New York Comic Con is an annual convention in New York City for fans of comics and pop culture. Redbubble is one of many exhibitors at this convention.

Redbubble held a show poster challenge: design a poster to publicize Redbubble’s presence at the 2012 New York Comic Con. The only requirements were that it mention Redbubble, New York Comic Con or NYCC, and the convention dates, October 11-14, 2012.

I did some research, and learned that much of the focus at the convention is on superhero comics. My brilliant concept: a Superworm emerging from a Big Apple covered with skyscrapers, and blowing soap bubbles– especially a big red one. Here’s a larger detail image:

detail image for Poster design for RedBubble contest for New York Comic Con comics and pop culture convention masked worm superhero emerging from apple representing Big Apple and blowing soap bubbles

There were 69 entries. Redbubble awarded first, second, and third prizes. The winner (left) and the runner-up are shown below:

first prize and second prize winners in RedBubble poster design contest for 2012 New York Comic Con comics and pop culture convention

Below, left: the third place winner. On the right: the most popular entry, which received the most votes from Redbubble members themselves. I really admire the bold design and energy of the latter, and I like it much better than the three winners.

third prize and most popular winners in RedBubble poster design contest for 2012 New York Comic Con comics and pop culture convention

So what did I learn from my learning experience? My conclusions:

BlankVertSpace.8pixels

A poster is usually vertical. My horizontal design was a mistake.

A poster is supposed to promote. My text was much too small.

Most entries had a single bold image. Mine lacked focus.

Mine was the most “cartoony” image. It may have appeared trite or disrespectful.

Giving my poster an “old paper” look made no sense– what was I thinking??

blank vertical space, 16 pixels high

  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

blank vertical space, 16 pixels high

Attendance at the 2012 conference over its 4-day run was 116,000. Here’s a shot of fans pouring into the convention center. I suspect there may have been a rumor that I’d be making a personal appearance… : )

big crowd of people arriving for and riding elevators to 2012 New York Comic Con comics and pop culture convention

A lot of fans dress as their favorite superheroes. These people look like they’re from New Hampshire.

couple wearing Spiderman and ninja manga superhero costumes and posing in front of RedBubble booth at 2012 New York Comic Con comics and pop culture convention

So do these people…

couple wearing clown style superhero costumes and posing in front of RedBubble booth at 2012 New York Comic Con comics and pop culture convention

And here I am, making my personal appearance. Just kidding. I’m not that muscular… : )

fat guy wearing some kind of boxer superhero costume and posing in front of RedBubble booth at 2012 New York Comic Con comics and pop culture convention

Note: the above four photos courtesy of Redbubble.

blank vertical space, 24 pixels high

What do you think? Did you like any of the NYCC posters? Ever had a poster that really caught your eye and stands out in your memory? Ever been to a fan convention or dressed up as a superhero? Hope you’ll leave a comment.

blank vertical space, 16 pixels high


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • The Worst Christmas Specials Ever. Still.

    Worst Christmas Specials Ever. Still.

    Exactly ten years ago I shared this wonderful relic of the Olde Days of the Blogosphere, by John Scalzi. It was old then, and it's even older now. Still make... Read more

    14 hours, 12 minutes ago by   Russellarbenfox
    SOCIETY
  • Happiness Is... Getting Used to the Mayhem

    Happiness Is... Getting Used Mayhem

    I know, half of the school holidays has gone by in a flash and we are nearing mid-December already! How can it be, right? That means we only have a few more... Read more

    15 hours, 42 minutes ago by   A Happy Mum
    FAMILY, SELF EXPRESSION
  • How Speaking Up Can Create Greater Happiness and Success

    Speaking Create Greater Happiness Success

    It's not always easy to find the words when you don't know what the reaction will be, but just how much do we avoid speaking up? According to research, 72% of... Read more

    The 11 December 2018 by   Ncrimaldi
    BUSINESS, CAREER
  • MDM Recordings Introduces TJ Miller

    Recordings Introduces Miller

    MDM Recordings unveiled a new member of their label family on Monday night at the Canadian Country Music Association office in Toronto, introducing a small grou... Read more

    The 11 December 2018 by   Phjoshua
    LIFESTYLE, SELF EXPRESSION
  • 15 Non-toy Gift Ideas for Kids

    Non-toy Gift Ideas Kids

    With Christmas just two weeks away, the pressure is on. And if your kids or the kids you’re buying for are like my kids, they really don’t NEED anything. Read more

    The 11 December 2018 by   Thesamanthashow
    LIFESTYLE, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Handle with Care: Consolidating Bill Traylor’s Artwork

    Conservator Catherine Maynor has extensive expertise caring for works on paper at the Smithsonian American Art Museum, including many by self-taught artists,... Read more

    The 11 December 2018 by   Americanart
    ART & DESIGN, CULTURE
  • Recipe: South African Three Bean Salad1 Min Read

    Recipe: South African Three Bean Salad1 Read

    Summer in South Africa means Braai - their word for BBQ. This light and bright salad makes the ideal complement to traditional BBQ fare. Serve it alongside... Read more

    The 11 December 2018 by   Healthytravelblog
    TRAVEL

Magazines