Debate Magazine

Tim Worstall on Top Form

Posted on the 10 November 2015 by Markwadsworth @Mark_Wadsworth

He has written this so many times he can probably write it in his sleep, but hey.
From City AM:
With calls to tackle “unfair dumping” should more be done to block cheap Chinese steel imports?
No

Far from rejecting cheap Chinese steel, we should thank the oppressed Chinese taxpayer for making us all richer. Subsidies are a distortion to a market and we normally don't like such distortions. But think through what the allegation here is.
The Chinese government is subsidising the price of the steel which is flooding out of China. Some call this a subsidy to those steel producers: it isn’t, it is a subsidy to steel consumers. That’s us, of course – we are all consumers of steel in tin cans, cars, fridges and the skeletons of lovely high rise buildings. This can indeed be seen as unfair on other producers of steel. But we don’t run the economy for the interests of producers; we run it for us, the consumers.
The Chinese government is, quite literally, sending us free money that it has taken from its citizens. This might not be a bright idea for the Chinese, but what else should we do but say “thank you. May we have some more?



Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog