Debate Magazine

The Students Who Were Happy When I Handed Them a Textbook (from the Archives)

By Stevemiranda

Very early in my teaching career, I taught an American Government class at a traditional high school. Every day I would bring a new idea to class that I hoped would engage the students: campaign finance reform, term limits, third party politics, and, since it was the major current event at the time, even the WTO controversy.

Every day was excruciatingly painful. I would stand in the front of the room and haplessly try to engage students in a discussion. The room was thick with a kind of tension that I couldn’t understand, but that was impossible to ignore. This lasted about seven or eight weeks.

Unable to stand it anymore and willing to try anything, one day I started class by asking students to walk to the bookshelf and grab a textbook. Then, I instructed them to open up to Chapter 7, write the answers to the “Questions for Discussion” at the end of the chapter, and define all the words that appeared in blue.

What happened next was incredible.

A cool breeze blew through the room, birds appeared and started chirping, and the sun began shining through the windows. Everyone smiled. A quiet calm settled in as students chatted effortlessly while they earnestly tackled the assignment. Everyone finished the assignment on time and some even thanked me as they exited the classroom.

The students had been waiting for this moment all semester. All they wanted was to be given a task and told what to do. And if you ask the folks who set up the education system in the 19th century—with the intent of training workers for a factory economy—if it was working well, I’m sure they’d offer an enthusiastic, “Yes!”

But this isn’t the 19th century. We don’t live in a factory economy.

We should stop using this structure.

We need to create something new.

(Join the discussion at www.facebook.com/reeducate. Get updates at www.twitter.com/reeducate.)


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Thomas Land | Drayton Manor Park

    Thomas Land Drayton Manor Park

    If living near a theme park was in your criteria for buying a house, then our new house would certainly meet that need. Living about a 3 minute drive from... Read more

    The 25 September 2018 by   Thefoodiecoupleblog
    FOOD & DRINK, RECIPES
  • Your Eye Drops Can Kill You

    Your Drops Kill

    Anything can be a poison, it all depends on the dose. This includes the drops you use to clear your eyes. The active, and dangerous, ingredient in many of... Read more

    The 25 September 2018 by   Dplylemd
    BOOKS, CULTURE, HEALTH, MEDICINE
  • The Wood Brothers: "River Takes the Town" & "Happiness Jones" Dutch TV Live...

    Wood Brothers: "River Takes Town" "Happiness Jones" Dutch Live Videos

    Watch roots trio The Wood Brothers perform River Takes the Town and Happiness Jones two tracks from their latest album One Drop Of Truth for Dutch music show... Read more

    The 25 September 2018 by   Hctf
    ENTERTAINMENT, MUSIC
  • Opera Review: Falling Down

    Opera Review: Falling Down

    The Met opens with a disastrous Samson et Dalila. by Paul J. Pelkonen A world of toil: Robert Alagna does hard time in Samson et Dalila. Photo by Ken Howard ©... Read more

    The 25 September 2018 by   Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA
  • Could Neanderthals Speak? Implications of FOXP2

    FOXP2 is one of the most famous genes out there; notable for containing two mutations linked to language in humans. These mutations are also in Neanderthals,... Read more

    The 25 September 2018 by   Reprieve
    BIOLOGY, SCIENCE
  • Diet Doctor Podcast #3 – Dr. Jeffry Gerber and Ivor Cummins

    Ivor Cummins: Great to be here, Bret. Dr. Jeffry Gerber: Thanks, Bret. Bret: The first thing I want to talk to you about is I learned from you guys you have t... Read more

    The 25 September 2018 by   Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE
  • North American B-25J Mitchell

    North American B-25J Mitchell

    @ Lancaster, CA March 2018 A B-25 makes a photo pass/bomb run during the the LA County Airshow.  This Mitchell, “Photo Fanny”, is part of the Planes of Fame... Read more

    The 25 September 2018 by   Htam
    PHOTOGRAPHY, SOCIETY