Instead, all his answers centered on what must happen for someone else, if we're talking "fruits worthy of repentance," as he put it.
There's an interesting twist. There is nothing you may do for yourself. Instead, there is everything you can do for your neighbor.
Like what? Like, live charitably. Collect honest taxes, no more than necessary. Do not use a public trust to extort money.
Can you imagine a happy land like that? A place where tax collectors collect no more than prescribed? Clothing bins for the poor are overflowing, and soldiers expect no more than their pay and do not ask for baksheesh.
None of those people could. That's why they needed a John the Baptizer to remind them of the fruits of their repentance.
Nothing of what he said is about "me." All of what he said is for somebody else.
Old John's version of Doomsday isn't about doom at all. In fact, it turns out to be about the "one who is coming." He's the one. He will do it. He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and he'll put a fire in your belly. You wait and see if he doesn't.
God sends the Christ, who gives his life for us each. It is this and this alone that gives life to the world. We can't strive for it. It is given. We don't earn it. It is free. It is not about "us" getting. It is about him giving.
The way of God is totally opposite from what we expect, even maybe from what we deserve. It contradicts how we experience life. "Tell me what I must do." And instead I am pointed gently to a neighbor. I am moved beyond my own expectations.
Henry Thoreau's notion of those who "march to the beat of a different drummer" is fetching. But here's Old John banging on a whole different drum set.
That is our situation as the Church of Christ on a sojourn in this place. Life around us has this steady pace of what's expected.
But John's pounding an expectant beat, and Jesus will arrive with a sweeter rhythm: Life is a gift. The kingdom is free. Christ is on our side. Grace and mercy have the last word. Look after each other.
Even now he is tapping out the sounds that measure our steps to this Table where his Body and Blood mark the dimensions of our need and his gift.
Russell E. Saltzman is a web columnist at First Things magazine and lives in Kansas City, Missouri. Before entering the Roman Catholic Church he was a Lutheran pastor. His latest book is Speaking of the Dead. He can be reached on Twitter as @RESaltzman