Everyone alive today could be fed, housed, educated, and cared for if we shared fairly. I believe that to be obviously the case, and furthermore that equality among all people on this planet is the core of everything I’m going to say. Equality is not a side issue, it’s the core. If you do not believe this, we are at an ideological impasse.
But I also want to say something that makes some on the left uncomfortable. There are too many humans for much of the rest of life on Earth to survive. Species are disappearing, and population size is part of that pressure, alongside our level of consumption. Fewer people, with everything else equal, means less pressure on other living things. And if I’m wrong about the numbers, if we are not too many to avoid extinctions, there is still no ecological downside to a smaller human population, and ecosystems will benefit either way. To be absolutely clear: no person alive is surplus. This is about the future, and about people choosing freely, over generations, to have fewer children. There will be social costs to this, like caring for an older population, but these are manageable if we opt fund care adequately.
Here are the numbers. We are about eight billion people now, and we are still growing, toward roughly ten billion later this century, around 2080. Fertility is falling, but growth will continue for decades from momentum alone.
I understand why this topic makes people uneasy. Population talk has a terrible history: forced sterilizations, the one-child policy, and eugenics, where some people were treated as less worthy of having children. That history is real, and it’s why I say plainly that coercion is wrong, and at the very least it fails morally. The data clearly shows that what works is voluntary action and care, and it is exactly what we already fight for: education for girls, contraception, health care, and an end to poverty. These are equality measures. Where women have education, security, and a real choice, fertility falls, freely and without force.
This is slow work. But decades are within our lifetimes, and the longer dynamics of ecosystems demand that we think past the next election. We should push both the fast and the slow solutions at the same time, and we need to start the slow ones now.
We cannot be silent about overpopulation. If we leave the topic alone, it will be taken up by people with the worst ideas, who will gladly fill the gap: the fascists, right-wing authoritarians, and the conservatives – all the people who would accept that some people are more deserving than others. The answer to those who would misuse a fact is not to deny it. It is to own it, on human-rights terms, ahead of them.
Let’s be clear about who is responsible for climate change and ecosystem destruction. The richest ten percent of humanity cause nearly half of global emissions, while the poorest half cause very little. A woman in a poor, high-fertility region is not the problem. So alongside lowering population by voluntary means, wealthy countries must radically cut how much they consume, and the deepest cuts must fall on the very rich. Since 1990, the richest one percent have caused roughly twice the emissions of the entire poorer half of humanity. But let’s also be honest with ourselves: the richest ten percent starts at an income that many people in wealthy countries earn. Most of us live far above what the global poor consume. This includes us.
That is what degrowth means. I’m with economists like Jason Hickel and Kohei Saito on degrowth and on anticapitalism. Degrowth means shrinking what the wealthy produce and consume, while raising consumption for everyone in need. It means an end to private jets and yachts, and an end to fast fashion for good. It means a radical cap on luxury, and a radical increase in housing, food, health care, and education for those who lack them. This is equality of consumption. But equality alone is not enough: sharing fairly does not help the living world if the total stays too high, so overall we must also consume less. It will be unpopular with some, but that is where I believe the evidence leads.
It also means care. A smaller, older population needs more care, not less: doctors, nurses, carers, and decent pensions. We can pay for it with the money we stop wasting on luxury and on war.
And that brings me to war. I argue that the military-industrial complex drives wars more than we are usually told. Arms companies profit when conflicts last, and they lobby for more. I know historians debate how much, and I might be wrong. But even if I am, the case against it holds. It pours taxpayer money into the pockets of arms companies, and makes a few very rich while others go without. It burns carbon. It takes money (i.e., resources) we need for health, schools, and the climate. War is also a question of equality: it takes from the many to enrich the few, and it falls hardest on the poorest and most defenseless. And lest we forget: war is bad in itself, killing children and civilians. An economy that does not run arms production for private profit removes the incentive to profit from war. Defending people against aggression can still be organized without anyone profiting from it, and that is a different question from the profit-driven arms trade. If there ever was a no-brainer, this is it.
None of this is easy. Some of it will be unpopular, if only because people like their precious things and are afraid to lose them. But we can only act on the evidence if we are willing to look rationally at all of it, including the parts that are uncomfortable for us. Sacrifices must be made, and the largest of them fall on those with the most, but most of us in wealthy countries will feel them too. And the thread that ties it together is equality: equal care, equal chances, equal consumption of what we need, and far less of everything else, with no one living on the planet’s resources while other people and species are left with nothing. That is what a serious left looks like.
Bjørn Østman, Odense, November 2026
Press enter or click to view image in full size
But my precious things…
