Numbers may feel instinctual. They may seem simple and precise. But Everett synthesizes the latest research from archaeology, anthropology, psychology and linguistics to argue that our counting systems are not just vital to human culture but also were invented by that culture. “Numbers are not concepts that come to people naturally and natively,” he writes. “Numbers are a creation of the human mind.”FWIW, it's not at all clear to me why the interviewer, Craig Fehrman, should remark that numbers may feel instinctual. After all we spent hours upon hours as children learning to count and then to do arithmatic, and this training goes on for half a dozen years.
I spoke to Everett by phone about the book.
Craig Fehrman: Are human beings hardwired to think numerically?
Caleb Everett: We seem to have some kind of innate predisposition to numbers, but it’s smaller than you’d think. At an early age, we have the ability to tell the difference between bigger groups — between, say, eight things and 16 things. We can also tell one thing from two things or two things from three things. But other primates like chimps can do that. And once you get to four things, it starts to get tricky.
CF: That’s where numbers come in, right? In your book, you suggest that our five-fingered hands — and the fact that we walk on our legs and keep those hands free — may have played a big role here.
CE: My suspicion is that there were many, many times in history when people realized in an ephemeral way that this quantity is the same as that quantity — that this five, in terms of their fingers, is the same as that five, in terms of goats or sheep. It’s no coincidence that many unrelated languages have a numerical structure built around 10 or that the word for five is often the same as the word for hand. Once someone else heard you referring to something as a “hand” of things, it became a cognitive tool that could be passed around and preserved within a particular culture.
CF: Once a particular culture has numbers, what does that allow?
CE: The way our cultures look, and the kinds of technology we have, would be radically different without numbers. Large nation-states aren’t really possible without numbers. Large agricultural societies aren’t possible, either.
Culture Magazine
These articles might interest you :
-
The Verdi Project: Rigoletto
In which our composer creates a sensation and changes the world of opera, forever. by Paul J. Pelkonen Tito Gobbi (with Renata Scotto) looking suitably... Read more
The 23 April 2018 by Superconductor
CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA -
the Ship is Sinking
Mishpacha Magazine (Hebrew edition) has been running an initiative recently promoting new young couples in the Haredi community take on their own mortgages... Read more
The 23 April 2018 by Gldmeier
RELIGION, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY -
Flower Power: Beyond the Beauty
If we could see the miracle of a single flower clearly, our whole life would change.” – Lord Buddha. Life is a journey that is full of special moments; like... Read more
The 23 April 2018 by Meet Rv
-
Dress To Impress! 5 Dresses For Your First Date
Are you looking to make a great first impression on a new man when you show up for your first date with him? Are you conflicted as to how to dress, what... Read more
The 23 April 2018 by Meet Rv
-
A RAINY DAY in VOLCANOES NATIONAL PARK, HAWAII
In the Kilauea Iki Crater in Volcanoes National Park, HawaiiA week ago, on our trip to the Big Island of Hawaii, Art and I were hiking across what felt like a... Read more
The 23 April 2018 by Carolinearnoldtravel
TRAVEL -
Congress Has Grilled Facebook CEO with Tough Questions Over Data Misuse
Mark Zuckerberg has faced Serious Allegations on Facebook Data breaching Scandal in two days Congress testimony –as it happened. Read more
The 23 April 2018 by Ruby Mariah
GADGETS, TECH -
Video of the Week: Anatomy of the Toes
In this lesson, we will look at the anatomy of the toes. I will also discuss how your toes move, what their functions are, and which kinds of common problems... Read more
The 23 April 2018 by Ninazolotow
FITNESS, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING