Books Magazine

Megan Casey Reviews All the Muscle You Need by Diana McRae

Posted on the 20 May 2015 by Lesbrary @lesbrary
Megan Casey Reviews All the Muscle You Need by Diana McRae

This, the only novel featuring Eliza Pirex, is surprisingly good. And for a surprising number of reasons. The writing is good, the mystery engaging, and the characters interesting. But that's just for starters. The best part may be that it is the most realistic description of being a private investigator that I can remember. Eliza, who speaks to us in the first person present, tells us about the criteria for becoming a PI in California, explains how her office is run, and lets us in on not only the primary case, but all her other cases as well. It is, in fact, a book about being a private eye. And at around 130,000 words, it has the length to tell several stories at once and to do it well. Published in 1988, it is a part of the first wave of lesbian mysteries.

On the surface, the book is about one woman's search for her college chum, who mysteriously disappeared six years before the book begins. But someone, it seems, doesn't want Eliza to find her. Eliza's other cases are just as interesting: moonlighting with a cleaning service at a local college to find the person who has been molesting women students, and investigating the acquaintances of another client, all of whom seem to take advantage of the gullible woman.

Eliza's love life, too, is interesting and fairly unique. She lives with a woman named Honor Sutton, who is a commercial designer, and Honor's two children, ages 7 and 12 from her previous marriage. Honor is cut from nifty cloth, not from the cardboard that seems to be the makeup of many of the love interests we read about. Her relationship with her odd family and her general daffiness give life to the book and even give reason not to dislike the odd book title, which is a phrase from Honor's promo campaign for Eliza's business.

Eliza is one of the only lesbian detectives I have read about to live with kids (Cherry Hartman's Morgan McRain and Tonya Muir's Lacey Montgomery are two others). Claire McNab's Carol Ashton has a young son who visits her, but who lives with his dad. Eliza seems like a real mother to her adopted ones. Her feelings for them are sensitive and believable (while Ashton's are often unrealistically gushy or mechanical rather than spontaneous) and her kids make up an important part of the interest of the book (while, again, Ashton's son just seems to be there taking up space.)
Eliza, however, can't seem to keep her hands off an old girlfriend, and when Honor finds out, there is hell to pay. As Eliza tells us,

"Women tend to be more monogamous than men. So in a relationship between two women, the odds that it is monogamous are good. I don't know why I stray against the odds every so once in a while. Probably because I'm a detective and we detectives have a yen for romance and adventure . . . "

Like most books, All the Muscle You Need has a few problems; one or two of the plot devices seem a little too hard to believe and Eliza Pirex is probably the worst-named character in lesbian fiction. On the whole, though, it works. A goodly number of stars for a early lesbian mystery that few people-even aficionados-have ever heard of.

For other reviews by Megan Casey, see her website at https://sites.google.com/site/theartofthelesbianmysterynovel/ or join her Goodreads Lesbian Mystery group at https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/116660-lesbian-mysteries

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Boeing 747-400, Lufthansa

    Boeing 747-400, Lufthansa

    @ Frankfurt Airport, Germany April 2018 Lufthansa operates 13 of these -400 models, along with 19 of the newer 747-8 aircraft. Read more

    10 hours, 21 minutes ago by   Htam
    PHOTOGRAPHY, SOCIETY
  • What ADHD Actually Is, Part 2

    Since I wrote part 1 of this series, I’ve had a lot of wonderful positive feedback from people with ADHD and suggestions for topics to cover in the future.... Read more

    11 hours, 32 minutes ago by   Brute Reason
    SOCIETY, WOMEN'S ISSUES
  • Pain De Mie

    Pain

    这个面包真的是超软!用刀切片的时候有点困难。Ingredients:260g Blue Jacket Baguette Flour40g Blue Jacket Wholewheat Flour8g fine sugar3g instant yeast1g salt180g water15g Cowhead salte... Read more

    11 hours, 45 minutes ago by   Cathysjoy
    FOOD & DRINK, RECIPES
  • Flash Fiction from a Writing Prompt

    Flash Fiction from Writing Prompt

    ** In the classes I teach at Stevenson University, students know that I have the propensity to use writing prompts in class to get them writing creatively and... Read more

    The 20 April 2018 by   Steph's Scribe
    BOOKS, ENTERTAINMENT, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Flash Fiction from a Writing Prompt

    Flash Fiction from Writing Prompt

    ** In the classes I teach at Stevenson University, students know that I have the propensity to use writing prompts in class to get them writing creatively and... Read more

    The 20 April 2018 by   Steph's Scribe
    BOOKS, DIARIES, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Inside New Opening Church on the Hill, Glasgow

    Doors Open at Church on the Hill Iconic Southside Glasgow bar, Church on the Hill, has opened its doors again, following a £650,000 refurbishment. Read more

    The 20 April 2018 by   Emma
    DESTINATIONS, DINING OUT, FOOD & DRINK
  • Summer Dresses Ideas

    Summer Dresses Ideas

    Coucou everyone,Summer is almost here, are you excited?Long days on the beach (in the park), light evenings with glass of rose on the terrace, delicious ice... Read more

    The 20 April 2018 by   Dusana Bozenkova
    LIFESTYLE