Culture Magazine

Knowledge as Intersubjective Agreement, a Quickie

By Bbenzon @bbenzon
There are matters for which we have methods that allow for “tight” intersubjective agreement. There are other matters which no known methods allow for “tight” intersubjective agreement. Science and math are as tight as these things get. Perhaps the revealed truths of religion are up there, but those truths turn out to be endlessly open to interpretation, and that can lead to sectarian divisions, which in turn give rise to some of the bitterest conflicts we’ve got. Then we’ve got simple matters like whether or not it’s raining outside. How do we settle those kinds of questions? We look out the window or step outside. Such matters generally yield intersubjective agreement.
And that, it seems to me, is the point: intersubjective agreement. That’s necessary if we are to speak of knowledge. But knowledge comes in all kinds, for there are many ways of reaching intersubjective agreement.
From my open letter to Charlie Altieri:
I am of the view that the rock-bottom basic requirement for knowledge is intersubjective agreement. Depending how that agreement is reached, it may not be a sufficient condition, but it is always necessary. Let’s bracket the general issue of just what kinds of intersubjective agreement constitute knowledge. I note however that the various practices gathered under the general rubric of science are modes of securing the intersubjective agreement needed to constitute knowledge.
As far as I know there is no one such thing as scientific method – on this I think Feyerabend has proven right. Science has various methods. The practices that most interest me at the moment were essential to Darwin: the description and classification of flora and fauna. Reaching agreement on such matters was not a matter of hypothesis and falsification in Popper’s sense. It was a matter of observing agreement between descriptions and drawings, on the one hand, and specimens (examples of flora and fauna collected for museums, conservatories, and zoos) and of creatures in the wild.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Dinesh Karthik Changes Fortune with a Great Cameo and Last Ball Sixer

    Dinesh Karthik Changes Fortune with Great Cameo Last Ball Sixer

    Not many may be remembering that 3rd ODI against England at London in Sept 2004 which India won by 23 runs and Sourav Ganguly was the man of the match. Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Sampathkumar Sampath
  • Sometimes…

    Sometimes life comes at you in unexpected ways. Sometimes straight on. You see it coming. You are either ready or not, but there it is. Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Redneckprincess
  • Change in Plans

    A few weeks ago I found a firm mass in my abdomen. I'm not very conversant with the usual makeup of my abdomen - it's not something I worry about most of the... Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Sherwoods
  • 6 Reasons Why Office Gossip Is Bad For Your Business

    Reasons Office Gossip Your Business

    As an entrepreneur, you should treat gossip among the members of your team as a reduction in productivity at best, and at worst, an indication of unhappy,... Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Martin Zwilling
  • #LondonWalks Walk Of The Week: Mountain Building & Meteorites in the City of...

    #LondonWalks Walk Week: Mountain Building Meteorites City London #UrbanGeology @R_Siddall

    On Sundays we pluck just one walk from the vast London Walks repertoire and put it centre stage. You can check out the full schedule at Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Lwblog
  • Hop Scotch


    Now there’s a touch of spring in the air, it’s time to resume with my travels, starting with a trip into the Kingdom of Fife for three of the matches in the... Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Smidrophenia
  • Bubble Guppies Live Review

    Bubble Guppies Live Review

    One night about a month and a half ago I was doing some work for my theater company, posting information about our upcoming production to various listings... Read more

    The 18 March 2018 by   Nesheaholic