Debate Magazine

Killer Arguments Against LVT Not (441)

Posted on the 16 May 2018 by Markwadsworth @Mark_Wadsworth

Here's a synthesis of a couple of wailing and bleating emails I've been sent recently, it's all boilerplate stuff:
Why go after little landlords like me? I've only got two buy-to-lets which I need for security in my old age (1). Would you rather I be a burden on the state?(2) If you want to get more tax, why not go after the big targets - home builders who own enough land with planning permission to build a million homes? (3) What about companies like Facebook or Google who make billions and don't pay a penny in tax?(4)"
Arrant nonsense if you actually think about it for two seconds.
1. Two is plenty. The trajectory is that one-third of households will be landlords with two buy-to-lets each and the other two-thirds of households will be their tenants. What security will the tenants have in their old age?
2. Old age pensioners get a state pension, and quite rightly so, it's a good template for a Citizen's Income. Are they all 'burden on the state'? I've not heard many people dare say it out loud or many landlords offer to waive their state pension entitlement. In any event, what happens when all those tenants retire and two-thirds of pensioners need housing benefit to keep their landlords in clover? Isn't that going to be a colossal 'burden on the state'? Landlords are already collecting nigh on £10 billion a year in Housing Benefit (twice as much as they pay in income tax).
(This segues into the Poor Widows in Mansions, who will be priced out of their homes and become a burden on the state. Glossing over the roll-up and defer option for that minority, if getting money from the taxpayer is a burden, then anybody who collects an old age pension without wanting to pay their fair share of LVT is also a burden on the rest of society).
3. At present, the home builders aka land bankers own land with planning permission for a bit less than a million homes, and I agree that politically, they are an easy target. But the UK's private landlords own five million actual homes - the land and the finished building. The total value of the land bankers' land is a tiny fraction of the total value of the landlords' land and buildings. Who's the bigger target here?
4. UK landlords collected gross £50 billion in rent last year, the banks took half in interest, minus bits and pieces, leaving them with £14 billion in net rental income. (Skip back a step - two-thirds of landlords' net rental income is taxpayer-funded Housing Benefit!). Facebook made worldwide profits of £4 billion-odd. Even we could identify (and tax) the UK element of Facebook's profits, it'll only be a hundred million or so. UK landlords' net rental income dwarfs Facebook's UK profits by a factor of a hundred-to-one. Ditto Google, Apple, Amazon and the rest of them. Who's the bigger - or easier - target here?


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • How I’ve Streamlined My Cleaning Routine with BISSELL

    This post has been sponsored by BISSELL ® . All thoughts and opinions are my own. Like most fur baby owners, I consider my tuxedo cat, Gideon, to truly be a... Read more

    The 24 May 2018 by   Francoisetmoi
    DESTINATIONS, LIFESTYLE, TRAVEL
  • "I'm Keith Hernandez"

    "I'm Keith Hernandez"

    There are dozens of books that come out every year about baseball, including memoirs from older players recalling their glory days. Read more

    The 24 May 2018 by   Theomnipotentq
    BASEBALL, SPORTS
  • The Golf Shots You Need To Practice to Score Low

    Golf Shots Need Practice Score

    To score well, there are some golf shots that are just more essential to learn than others - ones you need to practice to lower your handicap and make you want... Read more

    The 24 May 2018 by   Golfforbeginners
    GOLF, SPORTS
  • Himalaya Spring 2018: Last Teams Head to Summit, Others Cancel, and Further...

    Himalaya Spring 2018: Last Teams Head Summit, Others Cancel, Further Information Hillary Step

    The unprecedented climbing season in the Himalaya continues with yet more summits to report and a few remaining expeditions that are still unfolding. Read more

    The 24 May 2018 by   Kungfujedi
    OUTDOORS
  • Dog DNA

    The suspense is over and we now know what Jake's mixed-breeds are. Sort of. After impatiently waiting two weeks for the results of Jake's Wisdom Panel DNA... Read more

    The 24 May 2018 by   Hikingwithheather
    OUTDOORS, TREK
  • Planting Winter Squashes

    Planting Winter Squashes

    Right! My Squash plants are fed up with being confined to their little pots, they're going in!Over the last 10 days or so we have had a surprising (but... Read more

    The 24 May 2018 by   Mwillis
    GARDENING, HOME
  • You Are So Annoying

    Often after my seminars, parents come up to give me a personal greeting. Sometimes I meet parents who have been repeat attenders of my seminar. ( I love that). Read more

    The 24 May 2018 by   Joanigeltman
    FAMILY, PARENTING

Magazine