Society Magazine

"It is a Puerile and Pathetic Argument"

Posted on the 09 April 2013 by Brutallyhonest @Ricksteroni

When Elizabeth Scalia weighs in on a topic, she weighs in on a topic and here she absolutely skewers a popular argument made far too often by the unthinking who support gay marriage: 

Once having shed their own principles like snakeskin, the newly enlightened discovered that all other MarriageEqualityprinciples are illegitimate—not only illegitimate but anti-God, for we are told by Jimmy Carter, Stephen Colbert, Bill O’Reilly and others that if you look in the Bible, “Jesus never said anything about homosexuality or gay marriage.”

Of course, in chapter 10 of Mark’s Gospel Jesus states definitively that divorce cannot exist; these are his actual words, and they don’t matter a whit to our society, yet we must now glean our wisdom from the words Jesus did not say. The argument puts one in mind of a skit from Rowan & Martin’s Laugh-In, in which comedienne Totie Fields, dressed as an enormous toddler, sang,

Nobody told me that I couldn’t paint the baby
I was just told not to paint the walls and floors
but nobody told me that I couldn’t paint the baby
so I did.

For the five or six thousand years preceding the last fifty, no one needed an explicit pronouncement that marriage was an office involving opposite sexes because it seemed obvious. In the last half century, however, human sexual mechanisms have become utilized less for production and more for pleasure, and our national endorphin overdose has left us disoriented enough to argue that if Mom doesn’t say we can’t go skeet shooting with the good china, it must mean we can.

It is a puerile and pathetic argument, meant to guilt people into acquiescence, but since it is being entertained, we must ask whether it is true.

Please... read the rest.

She is appealing to people who think and she's doing so effectively.

Do you think?  If you don't, then frankly, until you do, it's hopeless.

But if you don't, it's not to late to start... and you can start by reading Elizabeth's entire piece... then, for the sake of all that is true and good, passing it along.


Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog