Debate Magazine

Iraq War Recriminations

Posted on the 18 May 2015 by Mikelumish @IsraelThrives
Sar Shalom
Of late, there has been much hand-wringing over statements by various Republican presidential candidates as to whether or not George W. Bush's war in Iraq was a mistake. Without addressing whether or not the war was inherently a mistake, the focus on that issue by those excoriating the various candidates defending the war sidesteps the issue of how the war was fought.
Discussing the merits of alternate ways of fighting the Iraq War is about more than being able to say that the war might not have turned out so bad if only it had been fought more smartly, though I am of the opinion that that is the case. It is also a matter of drawing the correct lessons from the war, lessons with consequences for how we approach the conflicts presented to us today that cannot be avoided.
Saying that the Iraq War was irredeemably a mistake and that no alternative approach to it would have changed that is saying that how the war was fought is irrelevant. If how the war was fought was irrelevant, then all that matters in war in general is whether or not to fight, and if so, how much force to bear. If that is the case, then all that matters in the conflict with Isis is bringing enough force to bear. If all that matters in fighting Isis is applying enough force, then there is no reason not to outsource the application of that force to Iran.
However, if your lessons from the Iraq War have to do with how it was fought, rather than the simple fact that it was fought, then one clear lesson is to avoid aligning yourself with those who pit one part of the population against another. In this regard, Iranian-aligned government of Iraq clearly pits Shia Iraqis against Sunni Iraqis, giving the latter no reason to support the overall state. A result of this is that the Sunni sections Iraq have become fertile ground for Isis takeover because while the locals might detest Isis, they detest the Iranian-aligned national government even more. The result is that while the Iranians might be able to remove Isis from a stronghold here and there tactically, they cannot remove the root cause of those strongholds' receptiveness to Isis because they are the root cause of those strongholds' receptiveness.
This brings up the entire justification for Obama's engagement with Iran. Obama claims that we need to go easy with Iran on nuclear negotiations and their sponsorship of instability across the world because we need their help against Isis. However, if Iran is part of the problem in terms of making the region hospitable to Isis, then there is no reason to include Iran in the coalition against Isis, let alone yield so ground in negotiations in order to procure that inclusion.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Opera Review: A Piece of Fairy Cake

    Opera Review: Piece Fairy Cake

    Joyce DiDonato sings a radiant Cendrillon at the Met. by Paul J. Pelkonen The lighting department: Joyce DiDonata as Cinderella in Massenet's Cendrillon.Photo b... Read more

    6 hours, 31 minutes ago by   Superconductor
  • What Mother Can’t Get Her Childs Birth Date Right?

    What Mother Can’t Childs Birth Date Right?

    I haven’t blogged in about ten thousand years. Since the Earth is only around 6 thousand years old, I take full responsibility for messing up that Math for you... Read more

    8 hours, 7 minutes ago by   Rachel Rachelhagg
  • FIREFIGHTER – Seattle Fire Department (WA)

    FIREFIGHTER Seattle Fire Department (WA)

    City of Seattle Fire Department, (WA) FIREFIGHTER Salary:  $72,900.00 annually ****To reserve your spot, please sign up!**** City of Seattle Fire Dept. (WA)... Read more

    10 hours, 10 minutes ago by   Firecareers
  • Afghanistan: Once Again a Pawn Between Two World Powers

    Afghanistan: Once Again Pawn Between World Powers

    by Jon PhillipsRESTREPO chronicles the deployment of a platoon of US soldiers at one of the most dangerous outposts in Afghanistan. Read more

    The 19 April 2018 by   Rvbadalam
  • Abu Dhabi to Dubai

    Dhabi Dubai

    Most of the people who are living in the United Arab Emirates. Trying figure out how to travel between Abu Dhabi to Dubai. On the positive side, traveling... Read more

    The 19 April 2018 by   Dubai City Company
  • Video: Kilimanjaro - Mountain of Greatness Trailer

    Video: Kilimanjaro Mountain Greatness Trailer

    This video is a trailer for a full-length documentary called Kilimanjaro: Mountain of Greatness. It follows mountain bikers Hans Rey, Danny MacAskill and Gerhar... Read more

    The 19 April 2018 by   Kungfujedi
  • A Full Spectrum of Poses and Practices

    Full Spectrum Poses Practices

    by NinaOne of the reasons I started the Photo of the Day project on Facebook was because of the way older people are typically portrayed in the media: almost... Read more

    The 19 April 2018 by   Ninazolotow