Evaluation of AIs as Article Reviewers

PREPRINT REVIEW
—————————
45 domain scientists spent 469 hours rating 2,960 individual criticisms from peer reviews of 82 Nature-portfolio papers, mostly from Nature Communications. The reviews came from both human reviewers and three frontier AI models deployed as tool-equipped… pic.twitter.com/PCIw096073

— Gabe Wilson MD (@Gabe__MD) May 22, 2026