Debate Magazine

Employment Vs Self-employment

Posted on the 18 August 2016 by Markwadsworth @Mark_Wadsworth

My post about the insane bribes for taxi drivers in Queensland turned into a jumbled slugfest about employment vs self-employment status.
In economic terms, there are people who are clearly employees at one end (where the employer needs the same people to come in and do a set job at pre-arranged times everyday - school teachers, bus drivers, shop assistants etc) via those who are self-employed at the other (plumbers, electricians etc who are called in when needed), all the way to (small) business owners. But there are massive gray areas where that can be reasonable room for debate whether somebody is actually an employee or self-employed in economic terms.
The distinction is important for at least three quite separate topics.
1. Vicarious and employer liability
An employer is more likely to be found vicariously liable for the acts of an employee and is also more likely to be liable for injuries etc suffered by an employee.
So if an employee in a restaurante deliberately ignores food safety measures and diners fall ill, the restaurateur is liable. And if the wiring in the kitchen is faulty and an employee is electrocuted, the employer is liable.
Conversely, if the restaurant orders ingredients which turn out to the poisonous and the same evening, diners fall ill, the restaurateur might (or might not) be able to escape liability and the self-employed supplier of the ingredients would be liable to the diners instead (he would be liable to the restaurateur anyway. And if the wiring in the kitchen is faulty and a self-employed electrician who is called to fix it manages to electrocute himself while doing so, then that is his tough luck.
2. Pay
An employee must turn up and be available for work whether there is anything to do or not; similarly, an employee expects to be paid whether he actually did anything or just sat around. If a role is redundant, then special rules apply, weighted in favour of the employee (fair enough up to a point - it is the employer's job to drum up business and he can be expected to plan ahead).
A self-employed person is only called and paid when needed and is usually paid by results (although a lot of rent-seeking businesses charge hourly rates whether they succeed or not). There are other rules to ensure that workers on zero-hours contracts are treated as employees, even though they would be self-employed under this test alone.
The government then messes things up by having the National Minimum Wage and Employer Pension contributions (a hidden tax and a massive subsidy to the pensions companies). The NMW simply does not apply to the self-employed, if you want to mow lawns or deliver parcels or drive a mini cab for £3 an hour as a self-employed person you are free to do so, and there is clearly no bar to the self-employed or small business owners making a loss, i.e. a negative effective hourly wage.
3. Taxation
Instead of taxing the least mobile and most highly visible source/flow of wealth (i.e. land and monopoly rights), most governments in their infinite wisdom tax the second least mobile factor of production - labor - at the highest rates. The effective rate on a basic rate employee, even ignoring VAT is about 40%, they just dress this up and split it into half income tax and the other half is split up into Employee's and Employer's National Insurance Contributions.
So there is every incentive for people to tweak things and present what is actually employment under the teal tests 1. and 2. as self-employment. HMRC has exactly the opposite incentive. Shiney gave the example of HMRC reclassifying partners in an LLP as employees. I could give the example of the extra 7.5% income tax on dividends to reduce the incentive for small business/limited company owners to pay themselves dividends instead of salary.
This is insane of course, to the extent that we have to tax incomes at all, it would be far better to tax all sources of income at the same rate to save arguments, rather than punishing employment status and then dreaming up endless anti-avoidance measures.
There, that is my non-partisan crash course in the topic. The problem is that most people start with the answer they want and then work backwards to the justification, for example saying that XYZ delivery company pays less than the NMW, thus automatically assuming that their delivery drivers are actually employed not self-employed.


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • How Does Smart Home Technology Impact Our Lives?

    Does Smart Home Technology Impact Lives?

    Smart home essentially refers to a home automation system under which all the electronic appliances in a house can be connected with each other over a digital... Read more

    12 hours, 8 minutes ago by   Kravelv
    HOME, HOME IMPROVEMENT
  • #FeedYourSkin with the ELEMIS Superfood Skincare Range

    #FeedYourSkin with ELEMIS Superfood Skincare Range

    By now, we're all aware of the vast benefits of Superfoods. They contain disease-fighting compounds and are either nutrient and/or antioxidant rich. You know... Read more

    The 24 February 2018 by   Glasgow Skinner/ My Life On And Off The Guest List
    FASHION, HAIR & BEAUTY, LIFESTYLE
  • Everyday Flossing: Waterpik Whitening and Sidekick Water Flossers

    Everyday Flossing: Waterpik Whitening Sidekick Water Flossers

    We've been smiling a lot lately. We'd love to say it's because life is absolutely amazing but it's because Waterpik has given us two things to smile about. So... Read more

    The 24 February 2018 by   Glasgow Skinner/ My Life On And Off The Guest List
    FASHION, HAIR & BEAUTY, LIFESTYLE
  • BNV002: That Vegan Conversation

    BNV002: That Vegan Conversation

    <Press the PLAY button above to listen to the podcast, or you can download it for later. > That Vegan Conversation Show Notes We’ve all had that... Read more

    The 24 February 2018 by   Chuck Underwood
    FOOD & DRINK, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, LIFESTYLE, VEGETARIAN & VEGAN
  • Snoop Dogg Inspiring Netflix Series “Coach Snoop” Is A Must See

    Snoop Dogg Inspiring Netflix Series “Coach Snoop” Must

    ChristianNews Snoop Dogg new Netflix series “Coach Snoop” shows viewers another side of the famed rapper from Cali. The 8 episode Netflix series, centers... Read more

    The 24 February 2018 by   Firstladyb
    SPIRITUALITY
  • Nuclear Accidents

    Nuclear Accidents

    diagrams: Chernobyl reactor before and afterNuclear fission is one of the world-changing discoveries of the mid-twentieth century. Read more

    The 24 February 2018 by   Dlittle30
    SOCIETY
  • Concert Review: A Cure for Pomposity

    Concert Review: Cure Pomposity

    The Vienna Philharmonic returns to Carnegie Hall. by Paul J. Pelkonen Gustavo Dudamel (standing) at the helm of the Vienna Philharmonic. Read more

    The 24 February 2018 by   Superconductor
    CULTURE, THEATRE & OPERA

Magazine