Debate Magazine

Devious Derogations

Posted on the 03 June 2011 by Humanwriter @roseforman

Most human rights treaties and conventions, with the notable exception of the African Charter,[1] contain a derogation clause. This allows the state to make the decision in “times of public emergency which threatens the life of the nation,”[2] to derogate from certain rights. States can act within their discretion, under the supervisory capacity of whichever convention they are deviating from, to apply the right of derogation. Certain rights, however, cannot be derogated from.In the International Covenant of Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) these rights include Articles 6,7 and 8. The right to life, the prohibition of torture and the prohibition of slavery. These are referred to as ‘absolute rights.’ However, this raises the argument that other rights are therefore not absolute. If other rights can be derogated from in times of public emergency, potentially at a time when individuals are most in need of protecting their rights, then they are not universally adhered to. Derogation from rights directly contradicts the opening statement in the preamble of the ICCPR, “recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family.”This Covenant is not alone in hypocritically stating that rights are both ‘inalienable’ or unchangeable and derogable when the state feels necessary. Brems suggests that “if no opening for derogation is left, a state might feel tempted in such as situation to disregard human rights at wish.”[3] However, if this is the case that states feel the need to disregard human rights then they are not fulfilling the requirements of the conventions of which they are party to. The ICCPR outlines “the obligation of States under the Charter of the United Nations to promote universal respect for, and observance of, human rights and freedoms.”[4] There should, therefore, be no exceptions which allows for certain human’s rights to be neglected.Article 9 of the ICCPR, for example, is one of the rights which can be legally derogated from in times of public emergency, it requires that “everyone has the right to liberty and security of person. No one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest or detention.” In the midst of the ‘war on terrorism’ some states have opted to derogate from such rights, especially in terms of infinite detention or detention without trial. In the case of Van Alphen v. The Netherlands the Human Rights Committee stated that detention ‘must not only be lawful but reasonable in all the circumstances’ and interference should be proportionate. A lot of discretion is left to the state to decide what is proportionate or necessary, “it is difficult to see how the detention of non-suspects for the purpose of questioning and intelligence gathering can be regarded as ‘necessary and reasonable in all the circumstances.’”[5]Is there ever a need to derogate from human rights? Surely as human beings, no matter who we are we all deserve to be treated equally with the same rights? And if not, are these Human rights at all? 

[1] Eva Brems, Human Rights: Universality and Diversity (Kluwer Law International 2001) 125 [2] International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) Article 4 (1) [3] Brems (n 1) 125 [4] ICCPR, Preamble [5] Christopher Michaelsen, ‘Derogating from International Human Rights Obligations in the ‘War Against Terrorism’?- A British- Australian Perspective,’ (2005) 17 Terrorism and Political Violence. 131, 135-136

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Big Food Giants Manipulate Public Health Policy in China

    Food Giants Manipulate Public Health Policy China

    Coca-Cola is at it again. As soda sales decline in the United States and Europe, beverage companies look to emerging economies like China for growth. And, it... Read more

    13 hours, 38 minutes ago by   Dietdoctor
    DIET & WEIGHT, HEALTH, HEALTHY LIVING, MEDICINE
  • Jewellery for a Precious You

    Jewellery Precious

    Jewellery is always close to a woman’s heart. It completes her look and boost confidence. Considering the changing trends in jewellery fashion, it becomes... Read more

    13 hours, 43 minutes ago by   Dr.jenifer Sayyed
    LIFESTYLE
  • Rajshri Productions’ Next Is A Film On Friendship | Hum Chaar | Trailer

    Abhishek Dixit’s debut feature film Hum Chaar is a Bollywood film made under the banner of Rajshri’s film. Hum Chaar is written and directed by Abhishek Dixit. Read more

    14 hours, 2 minutes ago by   Themoviean
    ENTERTAINMENT, MOVIES
  • Saint Paul the First Hermit

    Saint Paul First Hermit

    Today is the feast day of Saint Paul the hermit. This is a sweet and delicate Oatmeal Bread topped with rolled oats and naturally sweetened with agave. Saint... Read more

    14 hours, 7 minutes ago by   Veronica46
    FOOD & DRINK, RECIPES
  • Irupathiyonnaam Noottaandu | Teaser | Pranav Mohanlal | Arun Gopy

    Arun Gopy’s Irupathiyonnaam Noottaandu is an upcoming Malayalam action-drama feature film starring Pranav Mohanlal and Zaya David in the lead roles. Read more

    14 hours, 52 minutes ago by   Themoviean
    ENTERTAINMENT, MOVIES
  • A Year Of Body Positivity

    Year Body Positivity

    Last January, as I sat there on New Years eve all set to make the same old resolutions I've made year after year for as long as I can remember, I realised how... Read more

    14 hours, 58 minutes ago by   Sparklesandstretchmarks
    DIARIES, SELF EXPRESSION
  • Garden Bloggers Bloom Day – Jan 2019

    Garden Bloggers Bloom 2019

    Euphorbia rigidaWhen I went out to take the photos for this blog post I was surprised at how much was in flower dotted around the garden. Read more

    16 hours, 22 minutes ago by   Patientgardener
    GARDENING, HOME

Magazines