Science Magazine

Demise of the Australian ERA Journal Rankings

Posted on the 03 June 2011 by Bradshaw @conservbytes

Demise of the Australian ERA journal rankingsEarlier this week Australian Senator Kim Carr (Minister for Innovation, Industry, Science and Research) announced the removal of the somewhat controversial ERA rankings for scientific journals.

Early last year I posted about the Excellence in Research for Australia (ERA) journal rankings for ecology and conservation journals. To remind you, the ERA has ranked > 20,000 unique peer-reviewed journals, with each given a single quality rating – and they are careful to say that “A journal’s quality rating represents the overall quality of the journal. This is defined in terms of how it compares with other journals and should not be confused with its relevance or importance to a particular discipline.”.

Now, after much to-ing and fro-ing about what the four rankings actually mean (A*, A, B & C), Senator Carr has announced that he’s dumping them under the advice of the Australian Research Council.

Seems like a lot of wasted effort, but I’m sure most would agree that no type of ranking system is perfect. But one is necessary, no matter which way you slice it. Currently, the standard benchmark of a journal’s ‘quality’ is measured by the ISI Impact Factor – a highly controversial and somewhat simplistic measurement that relates to the ‘average’ citation rate of papers within. What I liked about the ERA rankings was that it seemed to do a pretty good job of ranking the journals within a particular discipline.

For example, a common lament among marine scientists is that marine science journals tend to be poorly ranked according to citations (e.g., Impact Factors), yet there are clearly ‘high-impact’ and ‘low-impact’ journals within that discipline. It was interesting to note that one such journal in which my students and I often publish – Marine Ecology Progress Series – received an ERA ‘A’ ranking, which as far as I’m concerned, was a fair assessment of that journal’s ‘internal’ reputation. I’m sure there are many, many other examples within other disciplines.

So for me it was a way of vindicating some publication trends within particular disciplines. Despite any ranking system’s limitations, I felt ERA ranking roughly emulated my impression of journal quality and impact – something Impact Factors only do partially (if at all). Therefore, I have to admit I’m disappointed they’ve been dumped.

Saying that, it’ll be interesting to see how they will be replaced. I know that the ERA assessments of university quality were more or less based entirely on citation data, so I dare say any new iteration will be citation-based as well. Back to Impact Factors, I guess.

CJA Bradshaw

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Long Walk 2018 – T Minus 3 Days

    Long Walk 2018 Minus Days

    T minus 3 days till the Great Long Walk of 2018 takes place. This year I’ll be walking from the tip of Cape Cod to the Sagamore Bridge at the base of the Cape... Read more

    The 24 September 2018 by   Wendythomas
  • Free CBD Vape Oil Sample : Pure CBD Oil, Miracle Drop, CBD Oil Benefits

    Free Vape Sample Pure Oil, Miracle Drop, Benefits

    Share This PostFree CBD Vape Oil Sample : Everything You Need To Know About Cannabidiol – 100% Pure CBD Oil, Miracle Drop Benefits – Now Available!... Read more

    The 24 September 2018 by   Tomkey
  • Stop Reading ‘How-To Raise Your Kids’ Articles. Midlife Margaritas Guide to...

    Stop Reading ‘How-To Raise Your Kids’ Articles. Midlife Margaritas Guide Raising Kids.

    I am a big fan of websites like “Grown And Flown” and “Scary Mommy”. They are filled with smart, funny and insightful articles about all the Mommy stages raisin... Read more

    The 24 September 2018 by   Midlifemargaritas
  • Favorite Movie #53: Bell, Book, and Candle

    Favorite Movie #53: Bell, Book, Candle

    Favorite movies that have had an impact on me - #53 - Bell, Book, and Candle (1958) - A middle-aged Jimmy Stewart may seem a strange choice for a romantic... Read more

    The 24 September 2018 by   Xoxoxoe
  • Magiczne Miasta: Włocławek Was 70 Not Out – I Have Visited 70 Places in Poland

    Magiczne Miasta: Włocławek Have Visited Places Poland

    “Someday you will find me, caught beneath the landslide; in a champagne supernova in the sky” – Noel Gallagher. Magiczne Miasta: Włocławek was 70 Not Out –... Read more

    The 24 September 2018 by   Northernirishmaninpoland
  • Wild Wood

    Here is Wild Wood! Wild Wood. 30″ x 40″, Oil on Wood, © 2018 Cedar Lee This painting was inspired by a photo my friend took on Wildwood Trail, a... Read more

    The 24 September 2018 by   Artbycedar
  • Video of the Week: Brahma Mudra

    Video Week: Brahma Mudra

    This version of Brahma mudra is a practice that includes both sound and movements of your head and neck. Practicing this mudra has practical benefits for the... Read more

    The 24 September 2018 by   Ninazolotow