Debate Magazine

A Question of Balance - The Supreme Court on Concealed Carry Restrictions

Posted on the 15 April 2013 by Mikeb302000
antonin scalia
Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia wrote the decision in a key 2008 gun rights case.(Photo: Paul Morigi, Getty Images)
USA Today
Guns are on the docket in Congress and dozens of state legislatures. Can the Supreme Court be far behind?

The court may decide as early as Monday to consider whether the Second Amendment's right to keep a gun for self-defense extends outside the home.

The case under consideration is a challenge to New York's law that requires "proper cause" to carry a weapon in public. Ten states, including California, New Jersey, Massachusetts and Maryland, have similar restrictions. Most have been challenged in court.

Whether it grants the petition from New York or waits for another case, the court is virtually certain to weigh in soon. That's because lower federal courts have issued split decisions on state laws designed to restrict the prevalence of handguns on the streets.

I was hoping they wouldn't vote on this until the balance on the Supreme Court changed. It goes to show you the capricious and political aspect of these votes.  It's simply a Question of Balance.

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog