Health Magazine

The “Broken Bone” Model of Addiction Treatment

By Dirkh @dirk57
The “Broken Bone” Model of Addiction Treatment
A word about chronic illnesses.
It’s not always easy to conceive of addiction as a complex disease—but it’s getting easier. There are certain similarities among chronic diseases. As with diabetes, asthma, and high blood pressure, drug addiction often requires protracted and multi-faceted treatments—treatments that typically do not produce the kinds of dramatic cures and breakthroughs that are associated with recovery from other kinds of medical conditions.
As we become increasingly comfortable with the concept of addictive disease, we risk losing sight of a crucial distinction between acute medical disorders, like infections and broken bones; and chronic disorders with multiple biological, psychological, and social components, like diabetes and addiction.
William L. White of Chestnut Health Systems, and Thomas McClellan, Executive Director of the Treatment Research Institute and until recently the deputy director of the Office of National Drug Control Policy (ONDCP) in the White House, co-authored a paper for Counselor Magazine that seeks to make the distinction clear. In “Addiction as a Chronic Disorder,” the two seasoned treatment professionals point out that “chronic care has to be quite different from acute care,” and that all treatments for chronic diseases like diabetes and addiction have three things in common:
1) They reduce symptoms but cannot affect root causes. Such treatments “do not return the affected individual to normal.”
2) They require major changes in lifestyle and behavior for maximum effectiveness. For example, “even if individuals with diabetes regularly take their insulin as prescribed, this will not stop disease progression if they do not also reduce sugar and starch intake, increase exercise and reduce stress levels.”
3) Due to their complex nature, “relapses are likely to occur in all chronic illnesses. Increasingly, family members are being trained to also provide continued monitoring, “ the authors point out.
So far, so good. But chronic care treatment is not what addiction treatment in America is really about. Addiction treatment in both medical and private settings is frequently governed by acute care thinking—the “broken bone” model of treatment. For example:
--“Services are delivered ‘programmatically’ in a uniform series of encapsulated activities (screen admission, a single point-in-time assessment, treatment procedures, discharge, brief ‘aftercare’ followed by termination of the service relationship).”
--“Services transpire over a short (and historically ever-shorter) period of time, usually as a function of pre-arranged, time-limited insurance payments.”
-- “The individual/family/community is given the impression at discharge (‘graduation’) that ‘cure has occurred.’”
-- “Post-treatment relapse and re-admissions are viewed as the failure (non-compliance) of the individual rather than potential flaws in the design or execution of the treatment protocol.”
Some fifteen years ago, the acute care model began to fall under increasing scrutiny as the neurosciences took wing and insights related to chronic diseases of the body and brain began to accumulate. As White and McClellan are at pains to point out, heavy drinking and other forms of drug abuse do not inexorably become chronic disorders. "Many substance use problems are developmental and as such are often outgrown in the successful transition from adolescence into adulthood. Others occur in tandem with major life transitions (e.g., death of a loved one, divorce, job loss) and are resolved by time, natural support, brief professional intervention or peer-based intervention by others in recovery."
It’s the same with high blood pressure: A period of hypertension may or may not lead to a chronic condition, and at present it’s difficult to predict whose high blood pressure is likely to prove resistant to changes in diet, exercise, and weight.
Beyond the matter of treatment, what do chronic diseases like asthma, diabetes, and addiction really have in common?
--They are influenced by both genetic and environmental risk factors.
--They have “a prolonged course that varies from person to person in intensity and pattern.”
--They are accompanied by “risks of profound pathophysiology, disability and premature death.”
--They have effective treatments, and “similar remission rates, but no known cures.”
If substance dependence is like other chronic illnesses, then two important insights follow: 1) “Acute care models of intervention for severe substance dependence may reduce substance use temporarily but those reductions are not likely to sustain once care stops,” and 2) “methods used in the treatment of other chronic illnesses might be effectively adapted to enhance long-term recovery from substance dependence.”
In the end, the authors argue that acute forms of treatment applied to a chronic disorder “offer an explanation of the generally high and rapid rates of relapse following cessation of most available addiction treatments: there is simply no quick fix for the most severe forms of this disorder.”
Graphics Credit:  http://www.mdjunction.com

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Ultimate Circuits South Africa 2017 – Updates 84 Hours

    Ultimate Circuits South Africa 2017 Updates Hours

    Ultimate Circuits South Africa 2017 - Updates 84 Hours Latest results posted at 84 hours. New 48 hour national age group record W60-64 for Martie Boesenberg wit... Read more

    The 25 July 2017 by   Abichal
    OTHER SPORTS, OUTDOORS
  • GABF Brewery Participation at Record Levels

    GABF Brewery Participation Record Levels

    Photo: GreatAmericanBeerFestival.com Every year about this time, beer-lovers around the country begin to start scouring the airline sites for cheap flights to... Read more

    The 25 July 2017 by   Marc Wisdom
    DRINK, FOOD & DRINK
  • Concert Review: The Last in Line Brought the Volume to Reggie’s

    Concert Review: Last Line Brought Volume Reggie’s

    Photo Credit: Josh Leep Last Thursday night, hundreds of people from all around the Chicagoland area (and some from further away then that) packed themselves... Read more

    The 25 July 2017 by   Urbanmatter Chicago
    TRAVEL
  • Off to Outdoor Retailer!

    Outdoor Retailer!

    I've only been home from Japan for two days and already it is time to hit the road once again. This time, I'm making the semi-annual trip back to Salt Lake... Read more

    The 25 July 2017 by   Kungfujedi
    OUTDOORS
  • Sedo Weekly Sales Led by Mondly.com

    Sedo reported their weekly sales and Mondly.com was the top sale this week at $25,000. Thf.org sold for $14,500 to lead the other gtlds. Crypto was a theme... Read more

    The 25 July 2017 by   Worldwide
    BUSINESS, TECH
  • Clean Energy For Anyone–Today!

    Clean Energy Anyone–Today!

    GR: Renters and homeowners, here’s an opportunity to switch all your electrical energy to renewable sources. The offer below is from Arcadia Power. Read more

    The 25 July 2017 by   Garry Rogers
    ANIMALS & WILDLIFE, BOOKS, ENVIRONMENT
  • Run, Bike and Party with Trikini

    Run, Bike Party with Trikini

    MANILA, Philippines – Megaworld Lifestyle Malls shall be presenting a unique active lifestyle event this July 29th, 2017 in McKinley West Park. Read more

    The 25 July 2017 by   Ethel Merioles
    DESTINATIONS, LIFESTYLE