Food & Drink Magazine

Baking Blunder Makeover (aka Bad Cupcakes Make Good Ice Cream Cake)!

By Dreenaburton @dreenaburton

Baking Blunder Makeover (aka bad cupcakes make good ice cream cake)!

easy ice cream cake with 'scruffy cupcake' base!

The last two months I've been in a spin.  Finishing final recipe test-runs for the book, cluing up writing and edits, and doing so while having my mother visit for 5 weeks followed by my parents-in-law visiting for 2 weeks.  Throw in activities with the kids and end-of-year recitals, concerts, performances, and hubby on a work trip, and you have one pooped mama.
This kind of chaos brings on recipe testing insanity.  You see, when I'm busy and stressed I tend to create - but not always in effective ways.  My mind gets overactive and rather than properly sort out a recipe, I instead go full-steam-ahead, blazing through my pantry, whipping out ingredients and pans and getting into tweaking recipes or designing new ones altogether.

Baking Blunder Makeover (aka bad cupcakes make good ice cream cake)!

baaaad cupcakes!

So, here I was with a manuscript due in 4 days, and I was baking cake after cupcake.  I was also preparing food for lunches and dinners for visiting grandparents, but instead of scaling back I decided to... "once again" test my gluten-free banana scented cake with one minor modification ("once again" happened 4 or 5 times)... try an altogether new raw chocolate mousse pie, which turned out fabulous but nevertheless required repeated tests for accuracy... and then test completely new variations on an orange-vanilla cake and chocolate cake/cupcake recipe.  The orange cake was a success.  The cupcakes, not so much.
At least I could push off all the 'good' cake tests on visiting family.  A friend also got a whole cake and the kids were toting cupcakes to share for a full week!  But, those chocolate cupcakes and cakes, I didn't want to give those away, not 'worthy', and I was fed up with running tests.  So, I scratched the recipe from the book, and moved on!  To ice cream.
See, when all else fails with baking, you can turn to your old friend ice cream.  Because it will solve your problem.  It is just waiting to make everything right in your day and with your baking.  If you treat it well - and I do! Yes, ice cream knows its place in my home.

Baking Blunder Makeover (aka bad cupcakes make good ice cream cake)!

pressing cake into pan

Baking Blunder Makeover (aka bad cupcakes make good ice cream cake)!

first layer of ice cream goes on!

I took my scruffy cupcakes and emptied them into a springform pan (which I first lightly coated with some coconut oil to make for easier slicing/removal of the cake).  Press that cake into the bottom and around the sides (partially) of the pan.  Easy breezy.  While doing that, you let a quart of ice cream soften at room temperature.  Then, scoop the ice cream on to the cake layer, and gently smooth/distribute without breaking up the cake layer too much (you can first freeze the cake layer to make this step easier if you like).  Once smoothed out, cover the pan with aluminum foil and pop this into the freezer to firm up that layer of ice cream.

Baking Blunder Makeover (aka bad cupcakes make good ice cream cake)!

and now the second layer!

You can stop right there... or, make it a little prettier by adding another different layer of ice cream.  This time you don't need as much, just a pint or less than a pint (alternatively, you can use 2 or three pints of different ice creams, freezing each layer before the next).  I chose chocolate, and again, softened that chocolate ice cream to layer on the frozen vanilla.  Smooth out, then back to the freezer.  Now, I could have sprinkled some toppings on this chocolate layer, like cookie crumbles, nuts, or a chocolate syrup drizzle - do so if you want!  But, I had other plans...

Baking Blunder Makeover (aka bad cupcakes make good ice cream cake)!

YUMMY!  Ice cream cake with fresh strawberry sauce.

Some fresh strawberries were sitting in my fridge.  A simple, fresh strawberry sauce was on its way.
This became our Father's Day dessert, and it was so simple.  This kind of dessert makes life a little easier during crazy times, because the prep is all ahead of time, and on the day all you have to do is sit and enjoy.  That I did - and so did everyone else.  Ice cream cakes are a snap to pull together, and yet never fail to impress.
There you have it.  Next time you have some botched baking (or, a half-dozen cupcakes hanging about the house) you're in business!

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Baking a Birthday Surprise: Chocolate and Ginger Cake with Orange Icing

    Baking Birthday Surprise: Chocolate Ginger Cake with Orange Icing

    We have a tradition in our family that we make the effort to make a birthday cake (if you’re at home for your birthday, that is). The problem arises usually... Read more

    By  Contemplatingtheclouds
  • Baking Croissants

    Baking Croissants

    Tweet I seriously need to stop day dreaming. It's becoming a sickness. This week, I keep drifting off, imagining myself as a small patisserie owner in Paris. Read more

    By  Fashiontofood
  • The Joys of Baking Your Own Bread

    Joys Baking Your Bread

    Waay back when we didn't have any children, I used to bake our bread and I loved it. There is nothing like kneading the dough, experimenting with different... Read more

    By  Smilinglikesunshine
  • German 'Gugelhupf' Makeover - Autumnal Apple Yeast Cake with Apple Cream Sauce

    German 'Gugelhupf' Makeover Autumnal Apple Yeast Cake with Cream Sauce

    As people we have always been told that fear is at the root of all evil and this is almost always true. However, I confess that fear is at the heart of this... Read more

    By  Weavethousandflavors
  • Easy Holiday Baking: Fruit Strips

    Easy Holiday Baking: Fruit Strips

    Tweet Baking is one of the best holiday traditions. Whether it is families or friends coming together to whip, whisk or wish for good results, by the end of it... Read more

    By  Fashiontofood
  • Check out This Amazing Basement/den Makeover

    Check This Amazing Basement/den Makeover

    I think we can all agree that the photo below is a pretty common, albeit horrible den. Well, Southern Living featured the makeover of this den into a living... Read more

    By  Decorology
  • Mom Makeover Contest

    Makeover Contest

    Are you a local mom who deserves hundreds of dollars in free stuff? Or do you know a deserving mom? It's that time of year again! You can now enter to win the... Read more

    By  Newsanchormom