Debate Magazine

Thoughts on School Reform

By Lawanda @lawanda43

An old belief is now reborn: if you don't have a degree in that subject, then you shouldn't teach that subject. Schools and districts are once again recognizing the importance of subject area knowledge. Of course, this would eliminate a lot of Teach for America candidates with business degrees, and it would stop someone with a communications degree from teaching high school English. But in my opinion, and from what I have witnessed lately, it's a rule worth enforcing.

In Texas, if you can pass the subject area test, then you are allowed to certify for that subject. The tests are not very difficult; I passed all four of mine on the first attempt. So, if I tried to certify to teach math, even though I have no subject area knowledge in that subject, and I miraculously passed the test, then I could become certified. No one analyzes my transcript for subject area background, and  I could immediately start calling myself a math teacher. This is a very faulty system because I should have been required to complete a number of core classes before standing up before students of my own. I should have a very high grade average in the subject I am teaching. 

In urban schools we are inundated with teachers without subject area knowledge. Many of these teachers have never belonged to a formal education program at the university level. Some of them have only had five weeks of serious training via Teach for America. Many others complete their alternative certification through a variety of sources, and almost none of these teachers belong to a professional organization in their teaching field. Those belonging in Kappa Delta Pi, or similar honor society, are likely less than one-percent.

In the very lucrative, for profit, arena of school reform, I suggest a fabulous way to save money: require teachers to know their subject, and carry this proof in their college transcript.


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Sustaining Democratic Reform in Burma

    Sustaining Democratic Reform Burma

    Burma took an unprecedented step toward true, representative democracy during its elections last April. Most notably, the National League for Democracy took... Read more

    By  Center For International Private Enterprise
    BUSINESS, CURRENT, POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • Tax Reform in Pakistan

    Reform Pakistan

    Pakistan is estimated to have one of the lowest tax to GDP ratios in the world, with only about 17 million of the country’s 176 million people paying income tax... Read more

    By  Center For International Private Enterprise
    BUSINESS, CURRENT, POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • Tucson Victims Call for Gun Reform

    CBS 5 - KPHO The TV journalist sounded as stupid as the pro-gun guys. After a clear explanation of why we need to close the private sale loophole because 40%... Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
    DEBATE
  • Normal Republicans Have Always Favored Immigration Reform

    Normal Republicans Have Always Favored Immigration Reform

    Although you would never know it from watching television during the past five years, Republican report for comprehensive immigration was strong before the Tea... Read more

    By  Alanbean
    SOCIETY
  • Obama Supports Filibuster Reform

    (caricature above is by the inimitable DonkeyHotey.)Majority Leader Harry Reid got burned two years ago. He had a handshake agreement with Minority Leader... Read more

    By  Jobsanger
    POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • Electoral College Reform

    I’ve been thinking about this issue since the ‘60s, when I wrote my first (unpublished) novel, about the mess of an inconclusive electoral vote when a... Read more

    By  Fsrcoin
    CULTURE, POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • Health Care Reform Didn't Go Far Enough

    This is a rather interesting graph from the Gallup Poll. It shows that while 57% of Americans are happy with the cost of their health insurance (most of them... Read more

    By  Jobsanger
    POLITICS, SOCIETY