Culture Magazine

Remembrance of Things Past

By Cris


The real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking new landscapes, but in having new eyes.”

– Marcel Proust

This morning I recalled the taste of a bit of madeleine dunked in a linden-flower tea which my aunt used to give me (although I did not yet know why this memory made me so happy). What prompted me to recall that although I have never sampled a madeleine or sipped linden-flower tea, I have read Proust’s paean to the immense architecture of memory?

The spur came from Daniel Engber, who wonders why certain scientific “discoveries” are made over and over. His prompting, in turn, came from the recent news that humans can echolocate and that the elderly are having lots of sex. Of course we have long known that humans can echolocate and that older people like sex. There is no new in this news.

While there is much to be said for the new, I am here concerned with the old — with scholarly works and archival materials that have either been forgotten or ignored. At least some of this forgetting is understandable.

It has only been in the past 15 years or so that formerly difficult to find and access materials (especially articles published in obscure journals and out of print books) have become electronically available. What formerly required weeks in a library can now often be accomplished in days while sitting at home.

Scholars who published books or articles before this time (circa 1995) can thus be excused for not being aware of all that which had gone before, and for not exhausting the possibilities of previous theory or research before moving on to something new. There is little excuse, however, for not considering such theory or research today.

Despite these facts, I rarely cease to be amazed at the ceaseless stream of recent publications which demonstrate little or no historical awareness of matters that previous generations of scholars have already considered, often in great detail. In some cases, what is presented as new is in fact quite old. In other cases, there is a great deal of unpublished and archival data that speaks directly to the issue under consideration but which is ignored.

How can we account for what appears to be a kind of academic amnesia? Part (or a good deal) of the problem stems from intense pressure to generate “original” data and publish on it. Never mind that similar or more relevant data have already been generated. These data, some published and some not, often beg for reconsideration or synthesis.

For that which is old to become new, we must first remember that it exists. We must then overcome market-like pressures which insist that for scholarship to be valuable, it must be based on “original” or “new” data — we have barely begun to exhaust the possibilities of the old and forgotten. In few fields is this more true than in evolutionary religious studies, which suffer greatly from a lack of historical awareness.


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Lace Up Pom Tree

    Lace Tree

    Without putting any much effort a summer dress can give us so much of goals from comfortability to enhancing our style to a new factor. If you're bored of the... Read more

    The 26 May 2017 by   Chayanikarabha
  • How to Know This is the Right Book to Read

    Know This Right Book Read

    In the past, people had to make an effort in order to get ahold of books they were interested in reading. Nowadays, though, they have an entirely different... Read more

    The 26 May 2017 by   Mariagrazia
  • Cheap Trick is Serving Pizza and Beer in Wicker Park

    Cheap Trick Serving Pizza Beer Wicker Park

    Greg Kot (left); Rick Nielsen (right) What’s more Chicago than pizza, beer and rock royalty all under one roof? You probably recognize Rick Nielsen as the... Read more

    The 26 May 2017 by   Urbanmatter Chicago
  • La Pinoz Pizza Offers Excellent Pizzas, Pastas, Tacos and More

    Pinoz Pizza Offers Excellent Pizzas, Pastas, Tacos More

    La Pinoz Pizza offers excellent pizzas, pasta, tacos, and more. But I feel there is a scope of some innovation and variation to, may be, attract a larger segmen... Read more

    The 26 May 2017 by   Jaideep Khanduja
  • Planting Trees Will Not Slow Global Warming

    Planting Trees Will Slow Global Warming

    GR: There’s lots of loose talk going around about “geoengineering” our way out of the climate-change disaster. I say it’s loose talk because there’s been no... Read more

    The 26 May 2017 by   Garry Rogers
  • The 3rd Annual Country LakeShake is Coming to Northerly Island

    Annual Country LakeShake Coming Northerly Island

    Grab Your Boots, Y’all! Tired of trekking to Wisconsin to enjoy a summer country music festival? Well, no shoes, no shirt, no problem, Chicago country music... Read more

    The 26 May 2017 by   Urbanmatter Chicago
  • Summer Decor Styling

    Summer Decor Styling

    This summer season I have chosen to keep my seasonal styling simplewith a wind of a coastal breezes.Air plants are even abundant in my decor right nowbecause I... Read more

    The 26 May 2017 by   Tamera Beardsley