Biology Magazine

Prediction Requires Data

Posted on the 08 November 2012 by Ccc1685

Nate Silver has been hailed in the media as a vindicated genius for correctly predicting the election. He was savagely attacked before the election for predicting that Obama would win handily. Kudos also go to Sam Wang,,, and all others who simply took the data obtained from the polls seriously. Hence, the real credit should go to all of the polling organizations for collectively not being statistically biased.  It didn’t matter if single organizations were biased one way or the other as long as they were not correlated in their biases. The true power of prediction in this election was that the errors of the various pollsters were independently distributed. However, even if you didn’t take the data at face value, you could still reasonably predict the election. Obama had an inherent advantage because he had more paths to winning 270 electoral votes. Suppose there were 8 battleground states and Romney needed to win at least 6 of them. Hence, Romney had 28 ways to win while Obama had 228 ways to win. If the win probability was approximately a half in each of these states, which is what a lot of people claimed,  then Romney has slightly more than one in ten chance of winning, which is close to the odds given by Sam. The only way Romney’s odds would increase is if the state results were correlated in his favour. However, it would take a lot of correlated bias to predict that Romney was a favourite.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Digital Maps and Social Data

    In the 80s and 90s, critical cartographers, such as J. B. Harley, reminded us that the map is not the territory. A map is always a representation, a... Read more

    The 11 March 2013 by   Sdlong
  • Charité Bien Ordonnée Commence Par Soi-même

    This French proverb is of medieval origin and is close to the following aphorism that is shared by Christians, Buddhists, Muslims, Jews and Hindus alike:... Read more

    The 05 March 2013 by   Fadi Bejjani
  • How Obama Won the Social Media Battle in the 2012 Presidential Campaign

    The 2008 Obama Presidential campaign made history.  Not only was Obama the first African American to be elected president, but he was also the first presidentia... Read more

    The 25 January 2013 by   Drpamelarutledge
  • DeMOCKERY is Not What the Greeks Intended It to Be

    Around 550 BC, the citizens of Athens and surrounding Attica invented the first DEMOCRACY, meaning "Power" (kratos) of the "People" (demos) in Greek. Read more

    The 09 January 2013 by   Fadi Bejjani
  • Hindsight Bias.

    Regarding the recent presidential election, do you feel that you knew the outcome in your gut all along? Not only felt it coming, but are sure you predicted it... Read more

    The 10 December 2012 by   Deric Bownds
  • Gopnik, Lamanite

    Insofar as I can tell, the only positive in this presidential campaign is all the light being shed on one candidate’s curious religion. For understandable... Read more

    The 12 August 2012 by   Cris
  • Do Scientists Know for Certain That Humans Are Causing Climate Change?

    It’s no secret that global warming has become a highly politicized talking point in the U.S. If you’ve been paying attention to the GOP presidential debates or... Read more

    The 27 October 2011 by   2ndgreenrevolution

Add a comment