Culture Magazine

Opera Review: Unhinged. Unmoored. Unsurpassed.

By Superconductor @ppelkonen
Riccardo Muti brings Otello to Carnegie Hall.

Opera Review: Unhinged. Unmoored. Unsurpassed.

Riccardo Muti leads the Chicago Symphony in Otello.
Photo by Tim Rosenberg © 2011 Chicago Symphony Orchestra

Otello, distilled expertly from Shakespeare by the team of  Giuseppe Verdi and his librettist Arrigo Boito, is the culmination of Verdi's art. This concert performance, featuring the Chicago Symphony led by Riccardo Muti, was vivid in its sweep and Shakespearean in its execution: the culmination of Maestro Muti's considerable skills.
Friday night also marked the conductor's triumphant New York return. Maestro Muti has had a rough 2010-2011 season, with health problems hindering the start of his tenure as the CSO's new music director. For their part, the orchestra responded brilliantly to his direction, with a muscular reading of the score that hummed with power and flexibility, from the fortissimo chords that kick off the storm scene to the haunted bass figures that presage the murder of Desdemona.
Over four acts, Maestro Muti led his audience down the emotional rabbit hole of Otello's decline. He was helped by a strong young cast, anchored by Latvian tenor Aleksandrs Antonenko in the difficult title role. Mr. Antonenko has sung this role under the Muti baton in Salzburg and Chicago. He has the right voice for this part, a dark-tinged, baritonal instrument that can rise up, find its volume and upper pitch, then slice heroically through a Verdi orchestra raging at full blast. He was especially chilling in the long Act III aria that follows Otello's degradation of Desdemona before the court, and the murder-suicide that ends the opera.
He was well matched with Krassimira Stoyanova, a picture of despair, emotional confusion, and more despair as Desdemona. Ms. Stoyanova brought warmth to the Act I love duet, creating the illusion of a perfect marriage before its methodical destruction. She sounded fresh and innocent in the Act II garden scene, interacting smoothly with a children's chorus and the men of the CSO Chorus. Her bewilderment in the third act, and resignation in the fourth felt entirely realistic, culminating in a Willow Song and Ave Maria that wrenched the heart.
Orchestrating events was Carlo Guelfi, a snide Iago whose chief quality was his eloquence of manner in his dirty dealings with the rest of the cast. Mr. Guelfi got off to a good start in Act I with a compelling Brindisi with Cassio (sung by the lyric tenor Juan Francisco Gatell.) He then poured everything he had into the Act II Credo: Iago's big aria where he tells the audience what an evil badass he is. However, his vocal level declined slightly over the course of the evening, failing to dominate the big ensembles of Act III. This was a competent performance, but not a great one.
The Chicago Symphony Chorus were one of the stars of the evening, forging the chain of "hit" choruses that raise the curtain on Act I into a cohesive whole. Whether they were singing about shipwrecks, victory, bonfires or the joys of wine, these singers lent a mighty voice, matching the orchestra in volume and power, creating tight sonic structures that struck the audience with the force of a raging maelstrom. Under Maestro Muti, the first and third acts were thrilling, but credit must also be share with chorus director Duain Wolfe.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • North American Opera . . . A Quiz

    North American Opera Quiz

    Winspear Opera House, Dallas, Texas March came in like a lamb today into the US Northeast where I live. And just as unobstrusively, Operatoonity’s editorial... Read more

    By  Galegirl
  • North American Opera . . . the Answers

    North American Opera Answers

    I promised answers to yesterday’s quiz today, and here they are. True confessions time: I didn’t have to work very hard identifying them. One reader, John Gilks... Read more

    By  Galegirl
  • Introducing the Opera Belles!

    Introducing Opera Belles!

    Three classically trained young singers have joined forces and voices to form the country’s first young female pop opera group. The Opera Belles, composed of... Read more

    By  Gibbs22manila
  • Murder at the Opera?

    Murder Opera?

    a novel by Margaret TrumanOnly on the page, I’m afraid.Though at least one opera singer in the US was believed to be murdered in the past year (according to... Read more

    By  Galegirl
  • Opera Review: The Bloody Return of James Levine

    Opera Review: Bloody Return James Levine

    Wozzeck at the Metropolitan Opera The Doctor (Walter Fink, standing) reminds Wozzeck (Alan Held) to eat his beans. Photo by Ken Howard © 2005 The Metropolitan... Read more

    By  Superconductor
  • Opera Review: Have More Fun in Bed

    Opera Review: Have More

    Le Comte Ory at the Metropolitan Opera Diana Damrau, Joyce DiDonato and Juan Diego Flórez get cozy in Le Comte Ory. Photo by Marty Sohl © 2011 The Metropolitan... Read more

    By  Superconductor
  • Metropolitan Opera Preview: Die Walküre

    Metropolitan Opera Preview: Walküre

    A rehearsal image of "The Machine", configured for Act II of Die Walküre.Photo by Yves Renaud, from a feature inArchitectural Record magazine. Read more

    By  Superconductor