Politics Magazine

Last Electoral College Post Till the Next One

Posted on the 18 November 2012 by Erictheblue

I've been thinking more about the electoral college--almost necessarily, for I sent an edited version of my last post to the Star Tribune, which published it as a rebuttal to the familiar defenses summarized, neatly but without irony, by D.J. Tice, and I have in the aftermath been hearing from people.  Thirty-one comments to the online version of my article!  I think that equals the number of all comments ever submitted to this years-old blog.  Who says traditional media is finished?  Not those of us airing our obsessions in the exurbs of the Internet.

I disagree with some people who seem to think of themselves as being on my side.  Keeping the electoral college, but dividing up the state-by-state award of electoral votes by congressional district (as Maine and Nebraska currently do), is neither a remedy nor a fair compromise.  In the real world, it would penalize Democrats for clumping together in the urban centers of the northern tier of states.  When all this year's presidential ballots had been counted in my district (Minnesota's Fifth, which includes the entire city of Minneapolis) and the one that adjoins it on its most northerly border (Minnesota's Sixth, represented by Michele Bachmann), Obama was ahead by well over 100,000 ballots.  But in the congressional district version of the electoral college, the count that mattered would have been 1 to 1.

Putting aside considerations of fairness, battleground districts are not an improvement upon battleground states, especially when there is an obvious remedy at hand--every vote counts the same, and the candidate who receives the most wins.  It's as if the electoral college is a bad habit that we can only hope to ameliorate.  No.  Just dump it.  Most votes wins.

I confess to being surprised when smart people think this question of the electoral college is a close call. Here is the usually sensible Michael Tomasky performing the on-the-one-hand-but-on-the-other dance.  His major point is that a national popular vote election would have a polarizing effect, since both sides would strive to "turn out the base."  But it's not as if both sides do not now attempt to turn out their respective bases.  The question is how many people are in those bases, and what do those who aren't in either one think?  It seems to me that statewide races, especially in large states, are an experimental laboratory that disproves Tomasky's theory.  As I pointed out in my article, Hillary Clinton, when she was running for U.S. Senate in New York, did not confine her effort to Manhattan.  Instead, she devoted most of her attention to parts of the state where her support was much lower than in New York City.  If you consult your own experience and observations, I think you'll conclude that my Clinton example is the rule--one for which exceptions are difficult to discover.  Why would a national popular vote election be different?

 


You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Fed’s Bernanke Faces Paul for Last Time

    Texas Congressman Ron Paul quizzed Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke for the last time on Wednesday, as the 76-year-old House representative prepares to... Read more

    The 19 July 2012 by   Dan90017
    CURRENT, POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • It Looks Like Last Night’s Debate Was Obama’s Triumph…

    Although I don’t think Mittens made any huge gaffes, he did tell a pile of obvious lies and Obama seemed to catch him on them. Read more

    The 23 October 2012 by   Btchakir
    POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • The Last December

    December 2012—it is supposedly the last month in the world. Yesterday did dawn with the date being 1212012, but since the local tree farm opened its gates... Read more

    The 02 December 2012 by   Steveawiggins
    POLITICS, RELIGION, SOCIETY
  • The Last Letter to Bush and Cheney

    The Last LetterA Message to George W. Bush and Dick Cheney From a Dying VeteranTo: George W. Bush and Dick CheneyFrom: Tomas YoungI write this letter on the 10t... Read more

    The 20 March 2013 by   Lowell
    DEBATE, POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • When’s the Last Time You Had a 7.73% Pay Raise?

    Fighting for a big raise…BART workers vote to authorize a strikeSFGate: Members of BART’s two largest unions voted overwhelmingly to give their leaders the powe... Read more

    The 27 June 2013 by   Eowyn
    DEBATE, POLITICS, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY
  • Three Oil Pipeline Leaks This Last Week

    First it was the Exxon pipeline near Mayflower (Arkansas) that dumped a few thousand barrels of oil (diluted bitumen) into the environment. Read more

    The 07 April 2013 by   Jobsanger
    POLITICS, SOCIETY
  • Gun Control Via Ammunition Control: EPA Shuts Down Last U.S. Lead Smelter Plant

    Despite the alleged massacre of 20 children and 6 adults at Sandy Hook Elementary School a year ago — “alleged” because the authorities still refuse to release... Read more

    The 14 December 2013 by   Eowyn
    DEBATE, POLITICS, SOCIETY, SPIRITUALITY

Add a comment