Current Magazine

Is It Really a Revolution?

Posted on the 19 March 2011 by Warigia @WarigiaBowman
In a recent email conversation with me, noted democracy scholar and Harvard professor Steven Levitsky made the following very relevant observation. 
"What we have so far in Egypt is the breakdown of an authoritarian regime, leading to some sort of regime transition.  We obviously do not know what will emerge.  In the best of cases . . . . . the outcome will be democratization (a democratic transition).  Alternatively, we may see some sort of hybrid or authoritarian regime emerge--almost certainly more liberalized than the previous regime, but nonetheless not fully democratic."
In other words, we are in a transition phase in Egypt. Currently we are emerging from a highly authoritarian and autocratic regime. The question is what regime will be next. Unfortunately, we really need to be clear that at the current moment, that is to say, at 4:36 p.m. on March 18, 2011, Egypt is being ruled by a military dictatorship. Today's vote is a very important step in the right direction, but the country is far from democracy at the present moment, and no regime transition has actually occurred. 

That being said, it is impressive that the first free vote is taking place in Egypt, so a democratic transition is definitely possible. In addition, there has been a real paradigm shift in Egyptian thinking. The Egyptian people are feeling empowered, and are finally demanding a responsive government.  In addition, Egyptians are discussing ideas freely for the first time. So, there has been a dramatic change in the national sensibility. This change of attitude, according to my colleague Mark Mikhail, may in and of itself be "revolutionary" 
If you wish to read more about revolution, I recommend the following documents. I will try to add to this list as time permits.
Theda Skocpol, States and Social Revolutions (London: Cambridge, 1979)
Clifton B. Kroeber, "Theory and History of Revolution," Journal of World History, Vol.7, No.1, 1996.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Labor Issues in Egypt Seen Through the Lens of the Revolution

    These represent partial notes taken by me at a conference. The conference was called From Tahrir: Revolution or Democratic Transition? June 4-6, 2011. Oriental... Read more

    By  Warigia
  • Musings Regarding the "Revolution Cabinet"

    Musings Regarding "Revolution Cabinet"

    The journey to democracy is long, and often lonely. Photo credit AFP. Dear readersIt is a lot, right? It is hard to follow Yemen, Syria, Bahrain, Jordan,... Read more

    By  Warigia
  • The Camden Cop Who Really Hated His Job

    Camden Really Hated

    The Courrier Post Online reports But an intensive investigation found the incident had been staged, said a knowledgeable source who spoke anonymously. Read more

    By  Mikeb302000
  • The Fourth American Revolution

    Fourth American Revolution

    Strauss and Howe, in "The Fourth Turning," were very accurate in their mid-'90s assessments of where we would be at this point in time. And Jim Quinn of The... Read more

    By  Jc_refuge
  • The Rehnquist Revolution

    A colleague of mine at PSCS called in sick today and left his lesson plans with me. For his Constitutional Law class, he wanted students to watch a video titled... Read more

    By  Stevemiranda
  • Revolution and the Ethics of Combating Corruption

    Revolution Ethics Combating Corruption

    Ziad Bahaa Eldin is the former chairman of the Egyptian Financial Supervisory Authority. He is a prominent figure in areas of corporate governance, rule of... Read more

    By  Center For International Private Enterprise
  • The Media - What Are We Really Trying to Censor?

    Media What Really Trying Censor?

    This post is a best of the best post on the topic of; the media as it relates to kids with special needs. Don't forget to check the BOB Site when it goes live o... Read more

    By  Gbollard