Biology Magazine

“God” Debate Straitjacketed by Myopia

By Cris

Over at Salon the MIT physicist and novelist Alan Lightman recently asked whether God exists, a question he poses in the service of reconciling science with religion and lambasting Richard Dawkins. Although he is an atheist, Lightman’s accomodationist query prompted a predictable response from Daniel Dennett, to which Lightman has responded.

It is a thoughtful exchange but contains nothing new. Similar debates have been ongoing for well over a century without advance or resolution. Science and religion debates which take “God” as a starting point are myopic. They begin with the false assumption that humans throughout history have been preoccupied with the idea of God, and that the monotheistic concept of God is the starting point for this kind of inquiry. Such assumptions are usually embedded in a Whiggish or progressive religious history with “God” being the apotheosis of supernatural thinking.

“God” Debate Straitjacketed by Myopia

The kind of “God” that Lightman discusses is a relatively recent idea, limited in time and space, that ignores religious history and diversity. We can see this in the definitions Lightman proposes:

For the purposes of this discussion, and in agreement with almost all religions, God is a being not restricted by the laws that govern matter and energy in the physical universe. In other words, God exists outside matter and energy. In most religions, this Being acts with purpose and will, sometimes violating existing physical laws (i.e., performing miracles), and has additional qualities such as intelligence, compassion and omniscience.

We can categorize religious beliefs according to the degree to which God acts in the world….Most religions, including Christianity, Judaism, Islam and Hinduism, subscribe to an interventionist view of God.

This is just wrong. It is not true that “almost all religions” have this particular conception of “God.” Nor is it true that “most religions” subscribe to an interventionist view of “God.”

Humans have believed in the supernatural for at least 45,000 years and perhaps longer. The anthropomorphic and interventionist kind of God to which Lightman refers is perhaps 3,000 years old. This particular conception of God is limited in time and space. It is a modern God that derives primarily from the Abrahamic faiths (Judaism, Christianity, and Islam). It is not a majority God and never has been.

Because Lightman frames his entire science/religion discussion around the God debates that take place within his own high culture salon, his definitions are not a problem so long as they are limited to that tiny arena. But they are not generalizable.

While Western intellectuals may arrive at resolutions or accommodations they find satisfying, these say little or nothing about debates that haven’t existed throughout most of human history and which huge numbers of modern people without God would never even consider.


Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Lamar Odom – I Don’t Care

    Lamar Odom Don’t Care

    Perhaps you’ve heard that former NBA player and current Kardashian victim, Lamar Odom has fallen ill most unexpectedly. What kind of world do we live in where... Read more

    The 23 October 2015 by   Christopher De Voss
  • Unrest in Jerusalem: a Month of Terror Attacks Takes Its Toll

    Unrest Jerusalem: Month Terror Attacks Takes Toll

    Pixabay photoJerusalem and Israel proper is the location where our Holy God has put His name (2 Chronicles 6:6) and set up His people. (Zechariah 2:12).As a... Read more

    The 23 October 2015 by   Elizabethprata
  • Fennel, Onion, Apple, Cheddar, Ham and Sage Quiche

    Fennel, Onion, Apple, Cheddar, Sage Quiche

    “Are you making another pie?”  The Farmer was letting his curiosity show with perhaps a little cautious optimism.  After yesterday’s spectacular pumpkin pie,... Read more

    The 22 October 2015 by   Mimiavocado
  • The Millennium Way: An Interview with Alison Bagby

    Millennium Way: Interview with Alison Bagby

    This post is only tangentially related to rock climbing. It has more to do with bragging about how awesome we must be, because the people discussed below... Read more

    The 22 October 2015 by   Thervproject
  • The Pancake Kitchen, Seaham

    Pancake Kitchen, Seaham

    I love pancakes. With or without bacon and maple syrup. With fruit on and lashings of Nutella. Even just pancakes on their own with lemon and a sprinkle of... Read more

    The 22 October 2015 by   Hellofreckles
  • Video: Darklight

    Video: Darklight

    We love night riding, but we’ve never dreamed of doing anything like this before! That said, our budget definitely wouldn’t stretch this far. Read more

    The 22 October 2015 by   Grindinggears

Add a comment