Environment Magazine

Essential Predators

Posted on the 21 November 2012 by Bradshaw @conservbytes
Essential predators

© C. Hilton

Here at ConservationBytes.com, My contributors and I have highlighted the important regulating role of predators in myriad systems. We have written extensively on the mesopredator release concept applied to dingos, sharks and coyotes, but we haven’t really expanded on the broader role of predators in more complex systems.

This week comes an elegant experimental study (and how I love good experimental evidence of complex ecological processes and how they affect population persistence and ecosystem stability, resilience and productivity) demonstrating, once again, just how important predators are for healthy ecosystems. Long story short – if your predators are not doing well, chances are the rest of the ecosystem is performing poorly.

Today’s latest evidence comes from on an inshore marine system in Ireland involving crabs (Carcinus maenas), whelks (Nucella lapillus), gastropd grazers (Patella vulgata, Littorina littorea and Gibbula umbilicalis), mussels (Mytilus edulis) and macroalgae. Published in Journal of Animal Ecology, O’Connor and colleagues’ paper (Distinguishing between direct and indirect effects of predators in complex ecosystems) explains how their controlled experimental removals of different combinations of predators (crabs & whelks) and their herbivore prey (mussels & gastropods) affected primary producer (macroalgae) diversity and cover (see Figure below and caption from O’Connor et al.).

Essential predators

(a) Simplified trophic interaction network of a moderately exposed rocky shore, with the components whose presence was manipulated and highlighted in red. While mussels might not interact trophically with benthic macroalgae consistently, they can comprise important consumers of algal propagules and also have strong non-trophic interactions with macroalgae arising primarily from competition for space on the shore, which might also interact with the presence of grazers. Such strong non-trophic interactions are largely absent from food web-based theoretical frameworks yet play a key role in determining the structure of algal assemblages. While crabs can feed on whelks, no predation by crabs on whelks was observed. (b) Experimental design comprising nine treatments, involving the removal of 2 species of predator and 2 groups of their prey, to measure the independent and interactive effects of predators on primary producers and test for direct and indirect effects across trophic levels.

While there were many complex interactions and outcomes of the removals, the gist of the experiment was that the loss of either predator ended up reducing the diversity and total cover of the macroalgae, mainly via the indirect effects of altered grazing abundance. They also found that shifting the dominance of one prey species to another completely changed the dominance of different macroalgae species. Thus, the top-down effects of predators on primary producers are utterly mediated by the relative changes in prey distribution and abundance. Great stuff.

The paper is worth a read, but has a lot of provisos, methods caveats and the (typical) pleas for more experimental work over longer periods. I’m just sticking with the main message here, but it’s another case of the complexity of ecology and the necessity of trying to examine simple effects from several different angles and under several different circumstances. Yes – we do need a lot more of such studies.

Chalk this paper up as another great example of good empirical evidence for the essential role of predators. Without predators, our feeble attempts to conserve ecosystems are doomed to fail.

CJA Bradshaw.

-34.917731 138.603034

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Causes, Effects and Solutions to Smog Pollution

    Causes, Effects Solutions Smog Pollution

    What is Smog? Smog is a serious problem in most big urban areas. The emissions from vehicles and industries as well as the combustion of wood and coal together... Read more

    By  Rinkesh
    ENVIRONMENT
  • Is Borax Safe?

    Borax Safe?

    Is borax safe?  You see, in my green cleaning kit I always have a box of borax to hand.  And every time I mention borax here on the blog a well meaning person o... Read more

    By  Moralfibres
    ECO-LIVING, ENVIRONMENT, FAMILY, LIFESTYLE
  • Why You Should Care: Trump’s Order on the Border Wall

    Should Care: Trump’s Order Border Wall

    GR: In the midst of the greatest mass extinction in Earth history, the U. S. government is stepping in to do even more to disrupt wildlife movements and put mor... Read more

    By  Garry Rogers
    ANIMALS & WILDLIFE, ENVIRONMENT
  • Koalas Are Fading Away

    Koalas Fading Away

    GR: I would add that not only are habitat losses causing greater short-term harm than climate change, so are invasive species. Read more

    By  Garry Rogers
    ANIMALS & WILDLIFE, BOOKS, ENVIRONMENT
  • Inaugural Environmental Arsehat of the Year

    Inaugural Environmental Arsehat Year

    As you recall, I asked both for your nominations and your votes for the inaugural Environmental Arsehat of the Year. Nominees could be a person or an entity... Read more

    By  Bradshaw
    ENVIRONMENT
  • Taking My Breath Away

    Taking Breath Away

    As a wildlife watcher there are spectacles I have seen that have taken my breath away, from thousands of Pink-footed geese taking to flight in the setting sun,... Read more

    By  Ashley Crombet-Beolens
    ENVIRONMENT
  • Maps Reveal How Global Consumption Hurts Wildlife

    Maps Reveal Global Consumption Hurts Wildlife

    Map shows species-threat hot spots linked to consumption in the United States. The scale bars indicate the total of all the fractions of threats to land or... Read more

    By  Garry Rogers
    ANIMALS & WILDLIFE, ENVIRONMENT

Magazine