Current Magazine

Constitutional Conundrum

Posted on the 16 November 2012 by Warigia @WarigiaBowman

The process of drafting the Egyptian constitution is turning out to be difficult, to say the least. Court cases, threats, and a debate over human rights are common occurrences. Further, a polarizing debate about the role of religion in the new Egyptian state continues to make headlines. One important debate is Islamist representation in the Assembly. Further, observers feel that the conservative language of certain articles may violate the human rights of religious minorities, women and even children. Liberal and secular groups are protesting the recent draft.
Human Rights Watch argues that the draft of the constitution provides basic political and economic rights, yet it falls short on women's and children's rights, freedom of religion, as well as torture. HRW believes that several provisions of the September 27th draft are at odds with international human rights standards. HRW tells Egypt to fix draft constitution (October 8, 2012)
Nathan Brown, a law professor at George Washington University, notes that the Egyptian constitution is not a secular document, rather it puts Islam at the front and center. Most of the 100 members of the Constitutional Assembly are Islamists, however, but Brown argues that they are trying to defer some major issues to get national buy in. Sharia law governing marriage, divorce and inheritance--which gives men and women very different rights-- will continue, although it has some language supporting the status of women at the beginning. In the long run, he notes, those provisions may come into conflict.  Brown states that "[l]iberals, secularists, Islamists, leftists, people from all across the political spectrum are having to hammer out an agreement, and they're not used to having to do that," yet he is hopeful that they will make it work. Looking to Rebuild, Egypt Leans on New Constitution (October 21, 2012)
Meanwhile, President Morsy has threatened to form a new Constituent Assembly if this one does not complete its work within six months. He also accused members of the former Mubarak government of sowing dissent in the country. Morsy puts pressure on Constituent Assembly (October 28, 2012)
The New York Times suggests that the new Constitution will insert religion more deeply into Egypt's judicial and legislative processes. Yet, the document firmly seats power in the hands of Egypt's elected officials and civil courts, so their is little likelihood that the country will become a theocracy as is the case with Iran. Liberal delegates believe that the guidelines are vague enough to give the nation flexibility with regard to interpretation in crafting the future Egyptian state. Egypt is the first Arab state to attempt to meld Sharia with principles of democracy. Tunisia is using a more liberal constitutional approach.A Vague Role for Religion in Egyptian Constitution (November 9, 2012)
Constitutional Conundrum Meanwhile, the Washington Post reports that Morsy remains firm in his support for Hamas, as he attempts to negotiate the delicate space between supporting the Palestinians, and honoring his treaty obligations with Israel. Thousands of Egyptians rallied in squares and mosques to condemn Israel's air strikes on the Gaza Strip, and to urge the Egyptian state to support the Palestinians. The post reports that Morsy has taken the lead among Arab leaders in confronting Israel. Egyptians Rally in Support of Palestinians in the Gaza Conflict (November 16, 2012)

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • What the Market Wants: It’s a Conundrum

    What Market Wants: It’s Conundrum

    It’s a ConundrumToday was a puzzling way to begin our new week: a brisk positive start gave way to the Dow’s inability to penetrate 13,000 for the first time... Read more

    The 21 February 2012 by   Phil's Stock World
  • What the Market Wants: The Continuing Conundrum

    What Market Wants: Continuing Conundrum

    The Continuing ConundrumAnother week of the same. Another day of the same. The news last week was generally positive with initial jobless claims remaining in th... Read more

    The 27 February 2012 by   Phil's Stock World
  • The Conundrum That is Jay Cutler

    Conundrum That Cutler

    Photo: Jonathan Daniel - Getty Images - Troy Ballard It's not easy being Jay Cutler. Think of the sideways comments, the unfair expectations, the constant... Read more

    The 21 September 2012 by   Beardandstache
  • The Vocal Rest Conundrum

    Vocal Rest Conundrum

    You would think that a person, alone in a house all day, could easily dedicate themselves to a necessary “vocal rest.”  But if it’s “me” we are talking... Read more

    The 01 December 2012 by   Shewritesalittle
  • The Biggest Conundrum: Energy Related CO2 Emissions and Human Development

    Biggest Conundrum: Energy Related Emissions Human Development

    Just this week the IEA came out with their report that 2012 had the highest CO2 emissions on record, largely due to increases in CO2 emissions in China and the... Read more

    The 05 December 2012 by   2ndgreenrevolution
  • The Compersion Conundrum

    Compersion Conundrum

    Compersion: Describing an empathetic state of happiness and joy brought about by knowing or witnessing the happiness and joy of another individual. Read more

    The 04 March 2013 by   Polysingleish
  • Cosmology Conundrum

    Cosmology Conundrum

    Some colleagues have suggested that my posting on Planck Day was overly frivolous, given the huge importance of what Planck has achieved. (Nicely written up by... Read more

    The 26 March 2013 by   Andyxl

Add a comment