Society Magazine

BOOK REVIEW: The Gold Persimmon by Lindsay Merbaum

By Berniegourley @berniegourley

Amazon.in Page

Out: October 5, 2021

This book consists of two stories with the common connection of being set in strange hotels. The first story is split between parts one and three (of three.) This allows part one to tell a story that feels like straightforward realism (while part three is where the story gets a bit trippy and where - in that trippiness - the reader may see connections between the two stories that may or may not be intended.) It's the story of Cly, an employee of a fancy hotel [The Gold Persimmon] that specializes in serving a grieving clientele, and her love affair with a regular guest, Edith, who is a physician. The strangest thing in this story is that Cly is probably the most attached to her job of any low-level hotel employee in the history of low-level hotel employees.

The second story's protagonist, Jaime, is an aspiring writer of nonbinary gender identification who is about to take a job in another hotel, a Japanese-style love hotel. [For the unfamiliar, that means a place with themed rooms where people come for short-term stays to get their freak on - think: dungeon, subway train interior, etc.] This story gets weird almost immediately as a fog descends over the city leaving only a few employees and customers trapped together inside the hotel. This is a much more engaging story than the other. The few people in the hotel inexplicably go all "Lord of the Flies," and the reader can't be sure whether it's descent into madness from whatever fog has enveloped the hotel, or whether they are mostly unstable from the start.

It's extremely difficult to write surreal- / madness-based stories that aren't distractingly unclear about what - if anything - is real. I felt this story suffered from two difficulties. First, Jaime's internal monologue sways radically from what seems like extreme paranoia to very reasonable states, but we don't know the character enough to have a baseline. Second, many of analogies used in describing events read a bit clunky, causing one to need to re-read to try to make sense of whether what is said is what is actually being seen or whether it's just a confusing metaphor.

That said, I was engaged throughout the story, and found it compelling enough to need to keep reading. I'd say if you don't mind some ambiguity and experimentation in writing, you'll enjoy this book. If not, not.

View all my reviews


Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog