Debate Magazine

A Jewish Feminist on the 2012 Election

Posted on the 03 February 2012 by Starofdavida
A Jewish Feminist on the 2012 ElectionWhile I won’t be ableto vote in the 2012 election (I’ll be a few months shy of 18), I still want toeducate myself and make sure I know where every candidate stands on the issuesthat are important to me, from Israelto abortion.
Obama claims to support women’srights, and he has done stuff to show that he’s not totally indifferent tofeminism. The first bill he signed was the Lilly Ledbetter Equal Pay Act, whichensures that women can sue if they don’t receive equal pay for equal work. He alsoappointed Hillary Clinton as his Secretary of State, and Justices Sotomayor andKagan to the Supreme Court. He wouldn’t expand an unconstitutional refusalclause that would deny contraceptive coverage to women who have insurancethrough a religiously-affiliated institution. (This is clearly not acomprehensive list.)
However, Obama has also disillusionedfeminists, too. His Cabinet member Kathleen Sebelius nixed over-the-counter PlanB for girls under 16, despite the FDA’s approval. Despite the fact that he sayshe’s pro-choice, there have been dozens of cuts to women’s health care andabortion centers on the state level. And let’s not forget the brouhaha over theHyde and Stupak-Pitts Amendments. (This, too, is obviously not an all-inclusivelist.)
In addition to his subparperformance with women’s rights, his decisions regarding Israel havebeen downright outrageous. I don’t know the solution to the Middle East Crisis,but I can tell you that reverting to the 1967 borders is not it. Jews havefought and died to ensure that the West Bankis part of Israeli territory. The idea of giving it up is offensive, an affrontto the memories of the thousands of Israelis who have been killed while protectingtheir homeland. Suggesting such a thing is just as stupid as saying that Americashould go back to its 1812 borders.
The Republican candidates don’treally seem to be such great friends of feminism. Newt Gingrich has proudlystated that he’s anti-abortion and wanted to defund Planned Parenthood. Mitt Romneyactually claimed to be pro-choice in the past, but he now calls himself“unapologetically pro-life.” So while they’re not really on Team Woman, let’sall bear in mind that President Bush was an anti-choice Republican in the WhiteHouse for eight years, and abortion is still thank God 100% legal. (I’m nottrying to downplay any damage done during the Bush era, but it’s important tokeep everything in perspective here.)
While the Republicans areanti-choice, they are definitely pro-Israel. Gingrich wants to bolsterAmerican-Israeli ties, realizing that Israelis America’s only true allyin the Middle East. He even went so far as tosay, “I think that we’ve had an invented Palestinian people who are in factArabs, and who were historically part of the Arab community. And they had achance to go many places, and for a variety of political reasons we havesustained this war against Israelnow since the 1940s, and it’s tragic.” Romney feels pretty much the same way asGingrich, adding that the reason there isn’t peace in the Middle East is because groups like Hamas have an agenda to destroy, notmake peace.
So this leaves me, as apro-Israel Jewish feminist, in a bit of a pickle. This is how I see it, inchart form, being measured in terms of bad, eh, or good:

Issue Obama Republicans

Women’s Rights Eh Bad

Israel Bad Good


It’s a sticky question with adifficult answer. But at the end of the day, what makes more sense - supportingbad + good or bad + eh? Obviously my mind may change by the time elections rollaround, but I really think I’m gonna endorse whoever’s running on theRepublican ticket.
Personally, I’m dying for DebbieWasserman Schultz to run for president, but that’s not gonna happen anytimesoon. Until then, I think a write-in vote campaign for Harry Potter will be ourbest bet.

You Might Also Like :

Back to Featured Articles on Logo Paperblog

These articles might interest you :

  • Feminist Dear Blank Please Blanks!

    As I've mentioned before, I'm a great procrastinator, and a particular fan of the website dearblankpleaseblank.com. I thought I'd share a few feminist-themed an... Read more

    The 09 January 2012 by   Starofdavida
    DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • Labeling Myself As A Feminist (Literally)

    the bumper sticker in question Right after we graduated high school, I gave one of my best friends a bumper sticker that read “This Is What A Feminist Looks... Read more

    The 15 February 2012 by   Juliez
    DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • Jewish Women and Space

    While most people don’t usuallyassociate Jewish women with space and astronomy, they have a surprisingly richhistory in the subject. Caroline Lucretia... Read more

    The 27 February 2012 by   Starofdavida
    DEBATE, RELIGION, SCIENCE, SOCIETY
  • The Perils of Being A Feminist in the Dominican Republic

    I’m currently a senior at my high school here in the Dominican Republic. I was born in the States and have lived overseas almost my entire life. I’m also... Read more

    The 07 March 2012 by   Juliez
    DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • Small Steps On The Feminist Journey

    I can’t pinpoint one event that transformed me into a feminist activist – rather, a succession of small personal events led to a decision to co-found my own... Read more

    The 12 March 2012 by   Juliez
    DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • A Feminist Education

    Feminism is a huge part of my life; it is as core to who I am as my hazel eyes or the heart-shaped birthmark on my calf. As such, I believe strongly in... Read more

    The 16 April 2012 by   Juliez
    DEBATE, SOCIETY
  • Blog for Choice Day: An Orthodox Jewish Feminist's Musings on Abortion

    Don't forget to submit an entry to the Second Annual Star of Davida Essay Contest!I thank God that I am able to say that today is the 40th anniversary of Roe... Read more

    The 22 January 2013 by   Starofdavida
    DEBATE, RELIGION, SOCIETY, WOMEN'S ISSUES

Add a comment