Wow..this stuff is seriously amazing. This ranks as some of the best shadow I have tried. The texture is perfection; so smooth and soft, but not too soft. With the shade Shameless Shana, there is no chalkiness and it is not powdery. Caught in the Act Courtney has a bit of a different texture; it is not quite as pigmented, feels lighter and seems a bit chalky to me. I like using this shade as a liner, which is what it is classified as. The staying power of both is amazing. They lasted all day with no fading or creasing. Shameless Shana is a gorgeous, shimmery bronze while Caught in the Act Courtney is a dark brown with copper microglitter. The packaging is also great. I love that they actually included a mirror and that it is magnetic, so there are no worries about it popping open. It is light weight and would be easy to travel with. I got these in a set that I found at Marshalls for $7.50 and it retails for $87, so it was quite a steal. The shadows themselves are $16.00. I would give Shameless Shana a 5/5 and Caught in the Act Courtney a 4.5/5 because of the slightly more chalky texture.Caught in the Act CourtneyShameless ShanaTop: Caught in the Act Courtney Bottom: Shameless ShanaAfter 6 hours.