That depends entirely on how one defines “sin”; it’s not as cut-and-dried as most people think. Did you ever read this? It’s one the 10 scariest short stories I’ve ever read. Now, a lot of people don’t think it’s frightening at all, and maybe even boring; this is because it’s all suggestion and nuance and shadows and no “the house is haunted because slave children were tortured there” modern pat origin BS. If you don’t have the kind of dark, shuttered rooms and bottomless abysses in your skull that I do, this tale may not take your imagination to the kind of utterly horrifying place that it takes mine. But if you’re a fan of Poe, Lovecraft, Benson, Blackwood, et al, you might find it at least creepy and worth your time, if not in your personal top ten. And if you do like it, here are my other nine; PDFs of 13 more tales are included.
No, we aren’t to Halloween season yet, but IMHO it’s never a bad time for tales of the macabre.