When I heard that actor Johnny Depp had bought the rights to the book - even before the book had been published - I was worried that the film would be an Americanisation of an English-set book, like another of Hornby's books; High fidelity. But, then the whole scene went silent for a really, really, really long time!
Until September 5th when it was announced that filming had finally commenced, whoop! So, this is when we also finally know exactly who has been cast:
Pierce Brosnan as Martin Sharp
When I read the book, I'm not really sure what I had in my mind regarding Martin's appearance, but in hindsight, I think that Brosnan is perfectly cast. He has that goodlooking charm that I can imagine oozing from the type of TV presenter Martin was supposed to be, and I can imagine it completely believable that someone like Brosnan (as in, how I can imagine he will play the character) could make the mistakes Martin made.
I can't imagine anyone else, who I believe, could play Martin Sharp. I'm definitely glad that Johnny Depp didn't take this role as I know a few fans of the book have speculated over the past few years.
Toni Collette as Maureen
I'm not going to deny that Toni Collette is not what I imagined for Maureen, in the slightest. I imagined a much older-looking woman, but reading comments from other fans, I think that I must be alone in that, but hey, reading books is all about personal interpretation right? But, Maureen is supposed to be 51, according to IMBd, Collette is 39...I dunno, I really do think that an older actress should have been cast.
I'm not really sure what I think to the casting of Collette, I'm a huge fan of her work in films such as Muriel's Wedding, About a Boy and The Sixth Sense, but I'm unsure how well she'll take to this role.
Aaron Paul as J.J.
Emile Hirsch of Speed Racer and The Girl Next Door was originally cast as J.J., but was apparently forced to pull out due to commitment issues. To be honest, I was a little bit disappointed to find out that Hirsch wasn't going to be J.J., because I think he'd have played the role well. But, I'm not going to dwell on that one too much.
Although he's been in quite a few things, I'm not at all familiar with Aaron Paul or his work, but I'll be intrigued to how he plays the role. He is, at the very least, American, so at least we won't be dealing with a dodgy accent. Personally, I always imagined J.J. to be good-looking but rough around the edges, so if Paul can pull that off (which I think he can), then I think I'll be happy!
Imogen Poots as Jess Crichton
I've only seen Imogen Poots in one film (28 Weeks Later), so it's hard to pass a real judgement, but whilst I can imagine her exuding a sense of wealth and self-importance, I'm not really sure that it's in the way that I truly imagined for Jess.
To me, Jess is a character that you are not necessarily meant to like, and generally most people probably won't feel like they can empathise with her. But, then you have to remember that the character is young, and at an age when we were all a little full of our own self-importance.
It'll be interesting to see how Poots plays it, but I'm not really sure I'm going to like her one bit!
One other query I have about the film is whether it is going to be set in England (where the book is set), or in America?