Pencil Vs Camera Popular in Primary and Secondary Schools

By Benheine @BenHeine

Since 2013, Ben Heine's Pencil Vs Camera concept has become popular among primary and secondary students especially in the UK and France. Heine was quickly contacted by art teachers and schools requesting to use and teach his techniques to their students. They would show them Heine's creative process through pedagogical worksheets and ask students to do similar images to stimulate their imagination, train their drawing and photography skills, encourage them to use new technologies and motivate them to share ideas and communicate. Heine's work also allows the teachers to discuss the differences between observational and imaginative drawing with the art class. 
Heine's creative techniques became part of art lessons in many primary and secondary schools worldwide. Different art lesson plans giving instructions on how to use his concept are spread by schools and art teachers on the Internet in France and in the United Kingdom (see below). Heine has also given frequent interactive conferences to schools in Canada. In June 2014, one of the classes studying Heine's concept in Belgium (Katholieke Centrumschool Denderleeuw) visited his studio in Rochefort (more info). 
Here below are some lesson plans examples based on Ben Heine concept for primary and secondary schools teaching Ben Heine's Pencil Vs Camera, followed by applications in art classes in the UK, France and Canada (this is a selection, there are numerous other examples in French schools, some of them referenced at the bottom of this post). If you're an art teacher, feel free to use or improve this material for educative purposes:

 Lesson Plan 1 / Lesson Plan 2 / Lesson plan 3
Here are some photos by Ben Heine with the drawing removed that teachers can use for their art lessons (you can find others here). Send us a message at info(at)benheine.com if you would like to use them in HD:


Applications in schools (selection) 
Dover College (Dover, UK)
Collingwood School(Vancouver, Canada)
Lander Valley High School (Lander, UK)
Bede's Preparatory School (Eastbourne, UK)
New Hope School (London, UK)
Padnell Junior School (Waterlooville, UK)
Madison High School (Madison UK)

Ecole Lamartine (Dunkerque, France)
Ecole Renaudeau (Allaire, France)
Ecole St Jean le Vieux (St Jean le Vieux, France)
Ecole de la Flotte en Ré (Flotte en Ré, France)




And here below is a full pedagogical worksheet example (art lesson plan prepared by Nicole Joly based on Ben Heine Pencil Vs Camera technique)
Grade 3-5 Drawing Lesson Plan 
Objectives 
The students will learn how to draw from observation, while also drawing imaginatively. They will learn basic photography skills to photograph a certain place in their town. They will then successfully use line, form, and value to create an illustration which adds a humorous twist to their photograph. The structural rules and conventions of an art form serve as both a foundation and departure point for creativity. Cognition and reflection are required to appreciate, interpret, and create with artistic intent.
Procedures 
1. Show the students various images from Ben Heine’s “Pencil vs. Camera” collection
2. Have them discuss the illustrations and the artist’s method of combining imaginative and observational drawing
3. Teach basic photography skills, such as perspective and cropping
4. Have the students take pictures around their town, with a digital or disposable camera
5. The students will be encouraged to think critically and consider what type of drawing they are going to place on top of their photograph
6. After the photos are printed or developed, demonstrate the process of taking a torn piece of paper and laying it strategically on top of the photograph
7. Encourage the students to consider placement
8. Discuss what it means to “continue the photograph” in their drawing, and also what it means to add an imaginative twist to the photograph
9. Demonstrate drawing a humorous image on top of my own selected photograph
10. Review concepts of line and form with them, and explain different ways to achieve value
11. Students will select their favorite photo and begin brainstorming clever ideas on some scratch paper
12. Once their idea is approved, they may begin working
13. Students will tape down a small piece of drawing paper to the photograph
14. They will use drawing pencils to create their illustration
15. After completion, the photographs will be displayed so everyone can have a laugh
16. This lesson would probably be a good lead in to a lesson on the Dada art movement Assessment The students will be assessed with a rubric which addresses effective photography techniques, creating and completing an imaginative illustration which “continues the photograph” and has value, using good craftsmanship, following directions, and participation.
-------------
Some other lesson plans examples and results in French schools:

Lesson plans / Pedagogical worksheets
Lesson Plan 1 / Lesson Plan 2 / Lesson Plan 3 / Lesson Plan 4 / Lesson Plan 5

Applications in schools (selection) 

Ecole de Scorbé-Clairvaux (Scorbé-Clairvaux)
Ecole Lamartine (Dunkerque)
Ecole Renaudeau (Allaire)
Collège F. Garandeau (Poitiers)
École élémentaire de Montgiscard (Toulouse)
Ecole Saint Jean le Vieux (Saint Jean le Vieux)
Collège La Bruyère Sainte Isabelle (Paris)
Ecole de Goyrans (Goyrans)
Ecole Coligny (Poitier)
Ecole Jean Yole (La Roche sur Yon)
Ecole Saint Jacques de Compostelle (Nueil les Aubiers)
Ecole Serge Lefranc (Saclas)
Ecole du Sacré Coeur (Plourhan)
Ecole de Mirambeau (Mirambeau)
Notre Dame de Campénéac (Campénéac)
Ecole Publique Saint Martin (Ardentes)
Ecole de Cheney (Dijon)
Ecole Daniel Faucher (Toulouse)
Ecole Sainte Agnes (Tours)
Ecole Descartes (Soisy sous Montmorency)
Other results: