What’s the Difference Between Life Coaching and Therapy? [Claude]

By Bbenzon @bbenzon

Once I began thinking about depression and its amelioration, I began thinking about therapy, but also life coaching. Why life coaching? Because it strikes me as being relatively new, on the one hand. Many people are being forced to change jobs because their current job has disappeared, either because it’s left the country (as steel-making largely has) or because it’s been rendered technologically obsolete. That’s a situation where life coaching might be called on, but also where depression seemed likely. So I asked Claude about life coaching.

As always, my prompts are in boldface, while Claude’s responses are plain.

* * * * *

Tell me about the profession of life coaching. When did it originate? What do life coaches do?

Life coaching emerged as a profession in the 1980s, growing out of the human potential movement and business consulting. Thomas Leonard, often considered the first modern life coach, founded Coach U in 1992 and the International Coach Federation (ICF) in 1994.

Life coaches help clients:

  • Define and achieve personal/professional goals
  • Navigate life transitions and decisions
  • Develop action plans and accountability systems
  • Identify limiting beliefs and overcome obstacles
  • Improve relationships, careers, and work-life balance

Unlike therapists, life coaches don't treat mental health conditions or focus on past trauma. They work with mentally healthy individuals to create positive future outcomes. Coaches typically meet with clients weekly or monthly, either in person or virtually, for 30-60 minute sessions.

The field has grown significantly - the ICF reports over 53,000 members globally as of 2023. While certification isn't legally required, many coaches obtain credentials through organizations like ICF or the Coaches Training Institute to demonstrate professional standards.

Compare life coaching with psychotherapy.

Life coaching and psychotherapy differ in several key areas:

Focus:

  • Therapy: Past experiences, trauma, mental health conditions, emotional healing
  • Coaching: Future goals, action plans, personal growth, skill development

Qualifications:

  • Therapists: Advanced degree, licensed, extensive clinical training
  • Coaches: Varied backgrounds, optional certification, no universal requirements

Approach:

  • Therapy: Diagnoses and treats mental health conditions, explores root causes
  • Coaching: Works with mentally healthy clients, solution-focused, action-oriented

Relationship:

  • Therapy: Clinical, bound by strict healthcare regulations
  • Coaching: More informal, partnership-focused

Duration:

  • Therapy: Often longer-term, addressing deep-seated issues
  • Coaching: Usually shorter-term, focused on specific goals

Both professions maintain confidentiality and aim to help clients improve their lives, but operate under different frameworks and serve different needs.

What about retirement coaching?

Retirement coaching is a specialized form of life coaching focused on helping people transition to and thrive in retirement. These coaches help clients:

  • Plan beyond finances, addressing lifestyle, relationships, and purpose
  • Structure time meaningfully after leaving work
  • Develop new interests and social connections
  • Navigate emotional challenges of identity shifts
  • Create phased retirement strategies

The field emerged in response to longer retirements and recognition that the psychological aspects of retirement require as much planning as financial aspects.

Unlike financial advisors who focus on retirement savings and investments, retirement coaches concentrate on the personal and social dimensions of post-career life.

What would a typical session with a life coach be like?

A typical 45-60 minute coaching session follows this structure:

Check-in: Client shares progress on previous goals and current challenges (5-10 mins)

Goal Setting: Coach helps identify specific objectives for the session (5-10 mins)

Exploration: Through powerful questions, coach helps client:

  • Uncover obstacles
  • Generate solutions
  • Challenge limiting beliefs
  • Create action steps

Action Planning: Client commits to specific tasks before next session (5-10 mins)

Sessions typically happen virtually or in-person, weekly or biweekly. Coach takes notes and may assign homework or exercises between sessions.

Do you have any statistics on how life coaching has grown in the last four decades?

Key growth metrics for life coaching:

1980s: Emerged as a profession
1995: ~1,000 professional coaches globally
2012: ~47,500 coaches
2019: ~71,000 coaches
2023: ~93,000 coaches globally

Revenue growth:

2019: $2.85 billion global market
2022: $4.1 billion global market
Projected 2030: $7.9 billion

North America remains the largest market, followed by Europe. Fastest growth is in Asia-Pacific regions.

(Note: These figures come from ICF and market research reports, but exact numbers may vary by source and definition of coaching)

I'm wondering how the emergence of AI will affect the profession of life coaching. AI is going to make some jobs either disappear and radically contract. It will change other jobs drastically. But it will also create new jobs.

AI will likely impact life coaching in several ways:

Disruption:

  • AI coaches may handle basic goal-setting and accountability
  • Chatbots could provide 24/7 motivational support and habit tracking
  • AI tools may automate routine coaching tasks like scheduling and progress monitoring

Evolution:

  • Coaches may need to specialize in areas AI can't match: deep empathy, complex emotional support
  • Hybrid models combining AI tools with human coaching will emerge
  • Emphasis will shift to uniquely human skills: intuition, authentic connection, nuanced understanding

New Opportunities:

  • Coaches may help clients navigate AI-driven career changes
  • New specialty: helping people maintain well-being in an AI-transformed world
  • Technical skills like AI tool integration could become valuable coaching competencies

The core human elements of coaching will likely remain valuable, but the profession will need to adapt to remain competitive.

I grew up in a world where you get educated early in life and then you enter the workforce in some capacity. You might then move from one film to another, but you’re always in the same line of work. Some people would even stay employed by the same company for their entire career. That world is rapidly disappearing. I’m thinking we’re moving into a world where job displacement will be routine. That is, it won’t happen just once in a person’s career, but it might happen 3 or 4 times, maybe every decade.

This shift suggests several key implications:

Career transitions will become a normal part of working life rather than disruptions. Workers will need stronger adaptability skills and comfort with uncertainty.

The role of education changes - instead of front-loading education early in life, continuous learning becomes essential. This includes both technical skills and meta-learning abilities.

Life/career coaches may evolve into "transition specialists" helping people:

  • Navigate repeated career changes
  • Identify transferable skills
  • Build resilience and adaptability
  • Maintain well-being during transitions
  • Plan financially for periods of retraining

This environment may require new social support systems and educational models to help workers manage recurring transitions effectively.