Plot
My musingsIt is a powerful, gripping movie which moves fast between past and present with the clear intent to convey the idea that they are inseparable in the mind of the protagonist. Young Eric, bravely facing the horrors of WWII, is played by a touching Jeremy Irvine, while aging Eric, still traumatised by what he survived, is an impeccable Colin Firth.
Firth interpreted a similar role in the 80s, he was Tom Birkin, a shell-shocked veteran from WWI in A Month in the Country. In a press conference for The Railway Man, he admitted that meeting Eric Lomax in real life and having him on set while shooting, gave to the fact to he was entrasted this role, a huge emotional charge which will resonate with him for a long time. Not an easy role - he added. Where can someone like me find all that pain and all that suffering inside himself? Impossible to relate to personal experience in this case.
What I love in Eric Lomax’s story is not only the analysis of the effects of brutality and torture on the human mind, but his personal journey from hate to forgiveness, which surprisingly brought him to meet again, and eventually to befriend, his torturer.
The scenes in which Eric comes face to face with Takashi Nagase, the man who tortured him during the war, are so beautifully delivered by Colin Firth and Hiroyuki Sanada, and they are so intense and so incredibly emotional that you can’t easily forget them. (you can see clips HERE and HERE)Two are the treasurable lessons I will particularly remember from this movie:
1. "When we surrendered, the Jap said we weren't men. 'real men would die of shame.'“ , Eric remembers. But to him, broken but never defeated, life is always worth living as the supreme, inalienable value. Not in one moment he sees death as an escape. This is something his antagonist, Nagase, says he learnt from the young man he tortured.
2.Almost at the end of the movie, Eric says: “Sometimes the hating has to stop” and the extraordinary lesson here is not just forgiveness, but, unexpectedly, even sympathy and friendship addressed to a person once deeply hated.
Eric Lomax is not a fictional character. He was a real man. A man from which so many can learn so much.