Format: DVD from Cortland Public Library on basement television.
The conceit of the book was that many of the months had full moons land on or around a specific holiday in that month—Valentine’s Day, Fourth of July, Halloween, etc, with everything winding up on Christmas. Moon cycles don’t work like that, of course, but it doesn’t really matter, and it was a fun way to look at each of the 12 chapters.
The movie isn’t going to do that. We’re going to start in late spring and end on Halloween. It’s more a summer of a werewolf, although a lot of the broad strokes of the story have remained. Our main character is wheelchair-bound Marty (Corey Haim), who will eventually be the one to susses out the reality of the werewolf and its human identity. Marty will be assisted by his sister Jane (Megan Follows) and his uncle Red (Gary Busey). There’s really only one person who can be the werewolf in this, but I’ll throw some possibilities into the mix for you. The sheriff (Terry O’Quinn) seems unable to solve the sudden spate of violent murders in the town. The local preacher (Everett McGill) has a massive upturn in business from this. Eventually, Marty will wound the beast, and we’ll learn the creature’s human identity shortly thereafter.
The truth is that Silver Bullet is a relatively tight little werewolf story. It doesn’t go anywhere too strange and doesn’t mess with the mythology at all. It’s very straightforward—the town is plagued by a werewolf for some reason, it goes on for several months, and then things get resolved the way that they’re supposed to with this kind of movie.
The truth is that there’s nothing really wrong with Silver Bullet aside from it being a bit simplistic. It doesn’t mess with the myths, but uses them well enough. It’s smart enough to give us a few scares and a bit of violence before wrapping everything up. The werewolf looks good enough, Corey Haim is surprisingly not that annoying, and Gary Busey is the right level of crazy. It’s perhaps a bit innocuous in that respect. It’s not bad, but that’s just it—it’s just not bad.
The biggest complaint I have is just how much this deviates from the source material. The entire point of the original book was to give us a werewolf story that took place over the course of a year, with the calendar essentially playing a part in the story actively. It was an affectation, but it was a god one, and one that worked. Silver Bullet cuts half of that, and except for the Fourth of July and Halloween, removes all of the holiday connections as well. The broad strokes of the story are here—Marty wounding the creature, the person who is infected, some semblance of the final battle, as well as the scene where the werewolf has a terrifying nightmare. This is good, but there are some great elements from the book left out.
Truthfully, Silver Bullet isn’t going to rewrite the werewolf movie, but it’s also not trying to. It’s entertaining enough to be worth a watch, which is more or less enough for any movie most of the time. I probably won’t watch this again, but it was fine to watch once. I do want to go find The Cycle of the Werewolf, though, and read it again.
Why to watch Silver Bullet: A fun werewolf story.
Why not to watch: Man, does this mess with the source material.