Nothing quite finishes Thanksgiving dinner like a freshly baked pie straight out of the oven. But let’s be honest- nothing quite tops a pie like sweet and delicious ice cream. While many families trod the traditional (and perfectly awesome) trail of topping their pies with vanilla, ice cream lovers might want to “wow” their guests with these amazing but totally approachable pie and ice cream pairings.
Apple Pie and Caramel Ice Cream
Let your guests enjoy the last bits of fall with a dessert that reminds them of crunchy leaves, knit sweaters, and the simple joy of a caramel apple. Top with a dusting of cinnamon for an extra elegant touch.
Pecan Pie and Butterscotch Ice Cream
Both warm and full of flavor, it is amazing that this pair rarely makes it into our holiday repertoire. Drizzle with caramel for something that will truly leave your guests filled with the warm joy of the holiday season.
Cranberry Pie and Cinnamon Ice Cream
While fruit pies are almost always a crowd favorite, they can also pack a serious extra punch of sweet. Round out your dessert with an ice cream that will add a touch of spice to your dish without overpowering the flavor. Cinnamon ice cream would also make an excellent topping for apple pies.
Pumpkin Pie and Molasses Ice Cream
Pumpkin pie is a versatile holiday favorite. It can be made with all sorts of additives and topped with whipped cream and a variety of different ice cream flavors. For a darker and richer pie, many people like to add a touch of molasses directly into their filling. For a lighter option, consider topping your pie with molasses ice cream instead. It will be sure to win over even your toughest pumpkin pie critic.
Cherry Pie and Chocolate Ice Cream
Instinctively, you might be already crossing this dynamic duo off your “to do” list. But before you make up your mind, ask yourself- “Who doesn’t like chocolate covered cherries?” Give it a whirl and surprise your taste buds with something decadent.
Beyond these five distinctive pairings, there is a whole world of creativity out there waiting to be devoured. May your season be filled with joy- and lots and lots of pie.