While the government shutdown is a serious matter, and is already causing damage to our economy, it pales in comparison to the damage that could be done by failing to raise the debt ceiling -- and we are within a couple of short days of doing just that. Republicans in Congress, especially in the House of Representatives, continue to threaten to block a raising of the debt ceiling. They either don't realize, or don't care, about the damage such a move could do -- not only to the American economy, but to the economic future of many other countries.
Some of these Republicans are now trying to minimize the realities of a government default by not raising the debt ceiling, but even their compatriots on Wall Street aren't buying that. They know serious economic damage would be done by failing to raise the debt ceiling, and like most other Americans, they want to end this nonsense now.
What are the facts about our debt ceiling crisis? Perhaps the best explanation, and the most succinct, has been given by Kevin Drum of Mother Jones. He explains it in only ten sentences. Here they are:
1. On May 19, total US debt reached $16.7 trillion, the maximum currently allowed by law.
2. The Treasury Department has been playing various games since then to continue paying all our bills while still technically remaining under the debt limit, but within a few days they'll run out of tricks and the government will no longer be allowed to spend more money than it takes in.
3. These Treasury tricks are very much not business as usual, and the fact that we've been reduced to these kinds of shell games means that normal governance is already dangerously crippled.
4. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that in FY 2014 (which runs from October 2013 through September 2014), total federal income will be $3,042 billion and total spending will be $3,602 billion, a difference of $560 billion.
5. This is the amount of debt we need to issue to pay for everything in the budget, which means that if the debt limit isn't raised, we need to immediately cut spending by $560 billion, or $46 billion per month.
6. That's roughly the equivalent of wiping out the entire Defense Department; or wiping out two-thirds of Social Security; or wiping out all of Medicaid + all unemployment insurance + all food assistance + all veterans' benefits.
7. What's worse, because the government's computers are programmed to simply pay bills in the order they're received, it's not clear if the Treasury can specify which bills get paid and which don't.
8. This raises the additional risk that interest on treasury bonds might not get paid—something that would put US debt in default and could be disastrous in a global economy that depends on US bonds being rock solid.
9. So those are our choices if Congress fails to raise the debt limit: Either we suddenly stop paying for critical programs that people depend on, or we default on US treasury bonds—or both.
10. The former would immiserate millions of people and probably produce a second Great Recession, while the latter would likely devastate the global economy.