Marriage Material

Posted on the 16 November 2026 by Sjhoneywell
Film: Keeper
Format: DVD from DeKalb Public Library on gigantic television. I’m starting to think that Oz Perkins is something of an acquired taste. Keeper was one of those movies that showed a lot of promise last year when the trailer dropped, but it disappeared pretty quickly. It also garnered Rotten Tomato scores below 50% both from critics and audiences. Why? I’m not sure, but I think it might be because rather than a traditional horror movie, Keeper is a dark fairy tale.

Malcolm Westbridge (Rossif Sutherland), a doctor, and his painter girlfriend Liz (Tatiana Maslany) are celebrating their one-year anniversary by spending the weekend at a secluded cabin. Among the things waiting for them in the cabin is a boxed cake that Malcolm says is from the housekeeper, a sort of personal joke. She leaves them a cake because she’s not a very good housekeeper. During dinner, Malcolm and Liz are interrupted by Malcolm’s obnoxious cousin Darren (Birkett Turton) and his Eastern European girlfriend Minka (Eden Weiss), who he claims speaks no English. Despite this, Minka warns Liz that the cake tastes terrible. Despite this, Liz chokes down a piece at Malcolm’s insistence.

Liz has a night haunted by weird visions of screaming women and a pregnant woman who looks suspiciously like her. That night, she wakes up and eats the rest of the cake despite the fact that there are a couple of severed fingers inside it. Meanwhile, Minka is attacked by something unseen while she is alone in the woods. Later the next day, Malcolm is called back to the city to deal with a patient who is coming out of a coma. Liz, left alone, starts to see creatures in the house around her, including versions of Minka and a woman with a plastic bag over her head. Darren reappears as well and seems very aggressive. Liz excuses herself to the bathroom and we see Darren grab a meat cleaver, but also see him killed by something unseen. Eventually, Malcolm returns to the cabin, and everything that has been happening gets something of an explanation.

It’s not a joke to call Keeper a dark fairy tale as we get into the backstory that explains everything that has been happening. Think of this as being very much in the vein of the Grimm Brothers at their darkest and most upsetting. Keeper doesn’t want to pull any punches with what is going on, and as the film spins into the third act, we’re going to go to some dark places, and some of what we are going to see is extremely upsetting.

So why did Keeper fail? Make no mistake—this is a movie that looked like it had some promise with the trailer, but clearly failed with both critics and audiences. Looking at this objectively, I think the problem is that Keeper desperately wants to create this sort of fairy tale storyline, but doesn’t take the time to establish the backstory. Oh, we’re going to get a backstory but there’s absolutely no real explanation of it. There’s a thing that happened (I won’t go into detail), and that is used without any further exposition to justify everything that happens. It feels hollow, like there’s five minutes of story here that were just ripped out, like the book was missing a couple of pages.

This is a shame, because Tatiana Maslany gives a compelling performance here of a woman who is trying to understand something that is clearly beyond her understanding. But even here, things feel truncated in a lot of ways. When we get to something like the payoff, Liz acts in a way that is ultimately believable, but entirely unsatisfying.

And that is the problem here. Keeper has a potential story here and there are plenty of things that could have made this interesting and understandable, creating a new sort of mythology, but we never quite get there. This leads to an obvious question—is the problem in the screenplay or is it in the direction? Or both?

Keeper should be better and could’ve been better. I really wanted to like this, and there are some crazy visuals in the third act, but there’s not enough getting there and not enough explanation for any of it.

Why to watch Keeper: That third act is crazy.
Why not to watch: If you don’t like slow burns, you’ll have a dull 70 minutes.