Aruba and St. Barthélemy (St. Barts) may both be Caribbean destinations, but they each possess their own distinctive charms that beckon travelers from around the world.
Aruba, situated just off the coast of Venezuela, enchants with its desert-like landscapes, pristine white sand beaches, and vibrant Dutch-inspired architecture. On the other hand, St. Barts, nestled among the Leeward Islands, boasts lush hills, picturesque bays, and an alluring fusion of French sophistication and laid-back Caribbean vibes.
LocationSouthern Caribbean, off the coast of VenezuelaCaribbean, located in the Leeward Islands
GeographyFlat, arid, and rocky; desert-like terrainHilly, volcanic island with sandy beaches
LanguageDutch, Papiamento, English, SpanishFrench
GovernmentAutonomous country within the Kingdom of the NetherlandsOverseas collectivity of France
CurrencyAruban Florin (AWG)Euro (EUR)
TourismMajor tourist destination known for its beaches and resortsExclusive and luxurious destination with high-end tourism
EconomyHighly dependent on tourism and oil refiningRelies on high-end tourism, luxury services, and small-scale agriculture
CultureRich mix of Dutch, Caribbean, and Latin influencesFrench culture with a blend of Caribbean influences
AttractionsNatural wonders, such as Arikok National Park and Natural PoolUpscale shops, gourmet dining, and pristine beaches
ClimateTropical maritime climate with constant trade windsTropical climate with mild temperatures year-round
Whether you seek thrilling water activities, cultural experiences, luxurious retreats, or a gastronomic adventure, these islands promise unforgettable journeys. So pack your bags and join me as we embark on a captivating comparison of Aruba vs. St. Barthélemy, exploring the very best each island has to offer.
Location and Geography: Contrasting Natural Charms
Aruba, a gem of the Dutch Caribbean, stretches over an area of 180 km², adorned with a desert-like terrain, cacti-studded landscapes, and wind-sculpted divi-divi trees. It’s positioned just 29 kilometers north of Venezuela, making it one of the most southern Caribbean islands.
The island’s flat topography is home to stunning white sand beaches on the western and southern coasts, which are shielded from harsh ocean currents, setting the stage for serene turquoise waters. The island’s northeastern coast, however, is more rugged and exposed, reflecting a different kind of beauty.
St. Barthélemy or St. Barts, a part of the French West Indies, is a smaller island at only 25 km², known for its rugged terrain encompassing steep, lush hills and stunningly beautiful bays. The island is nestled among the Leeward Islands of the Caribbean Sea, a region defined by tranquility and serene beauty.
Unlike Aruba’s desert-like environment, St. Barts boasts a rich and varied vegetation, with palm-fringed beaches meeting the forest-clad hills, adding to its paradisiac charm.
Each island’s unique geographic qualities have inspired distinctive architectural styles. Aruba’s architecture is influenced by its Dutch heritage and warm desert conditions, with low, rectangular buildings brightly painted in a rainbow of pastels. In contrast, the architecture in St. Barts is distinctly Swedish – a nod to its colonial history – with red-roofed cottages and gingerbread-trimmed houses.
The climate varies slightly between these islands too. Aruba enjoys constant trade winds that make the tropical climate feel less oppressive and keep hurricanes at bay. St. Barts, while also benefiting from trade winds, tends to be slightly cooler and more humid, with the possibility of hurricanes during the season, which has led to its lush vegetation.
Cultural Heritage: Unique Traditions and Influences
Aruba’s cultural tapestry weaves together influences from the indigenous Caquetío people, the Spanish, and the Dutch. The official languages are Dutch and Papiamento, a Creole language with Portuguese, Spanish, Dutch, and African influences, reflecting the island’s rich history. Aruban culture can be experienced in its lively music genres, such as soca, calypso, and tumba, and vibrant folkloric dances that often tell stories of the island’s past.
On the other hand, St. Barts holds a cultural blend of French sophistication and laid-back Caribbean attitude. French is the official language, yet English is widely spoken due to its international appeal.
The local culture is distinctly French, from the cuisine and wine to the fashion and annual events like the St. Barts Music Festival or the St. Barts Film Festival. This elegant blend of cultural influences gives the island a unique charm that’s simply irresistible.
Both islands host lively carnivals, a common celebration throughout the Caribbean. Aruba’s Carnival, a month-long celebration, is filled with parades, music, and dance, showcasing the island’s Dutch and African influences. In contrast, St. Barts’ “Carnival” revolves around Mardi Gras, embodying its French heritage with a parade of flamboyantly decorated floats, traditional music, and street parties.
Yet, these islands have preserved their indigenous roots as well. In Aruba, the Arawak heritage is kept alive through pottery, cave paintings, and the traditional caha di orgel music box. Meanwhile, in St. Barts, the Arawak’s influence can still be seen in the traditional craft of weaving latanier palm and the construction of local fish traps.
Beaches and Water Activities: A Comparative Analysis
Aruba, with its white sandy beaches and clear turquoise waters, is a haven for water sports. Eagle Beach and Palm Beach offer perfect settings for swimming, snorkeling, and sunbathing.
The island’s favorable winds and waves also make it a popular destination for windsurfing and kitesurfing. For those interested in marine life, the Antilla Shipwreck provides an exceptional site for scuba diving, teeming with tropical fish and coral formations.
In contrast, St. Barts offers a more secluded and luxurious beach experience. The island has 14 public beaches, each with unique characteristics. St. Jean Beach is renowned for water sports like snorkeling and windsurfing, while Colombier Beach, accessible only by boat or hike, provides a quiet retreat for those seeking privacy. For surfers, Toiny Coast offers consistent waves, and divers can explore numerous underwater caves and shipwrecks around the island.
Both islands prioritize marine conservation. Aruba has established several marine parks and underwater trails for snorkelers and divers, such as the Aruba National Marine Park. Similarly, St. Barts has protected marine areas, like the Marine Park of Saint Barthélemy, which contains five marine reserves, emphasizing their commitment to preserving their rich marine biodiversity.
As far as fishing is concerned, both islands have a lot to offer. Aruba is renowned for deep-sea fishing, with a chance to catch marlin, sailfish, and tuna, while St. Barts is popular for its traditional line fishing method, offering an authentic fishing experience.
Accommodation and Hospitality: Perfect Retreats
Aruba’s accommodation options cater to a wide range of preferences and budgets, from all-inclusive luxury resorts along Palm Beach to quaint, budget-friendly guesthouses. Hospitality in Aruba is defined by its warm, welcoming locals, known as the “One Happy Island” for a reason. Arubans are known for their friendliness and are eager to share their culture with visitors.
On the other hand, St. Barts is the epitome of luxury, catering primarily to high-end tourism. The island is dotted with upscale boutique hotels, villas, and private yacht charters. The hospitality in St. Barts is distinguished by personalized attention and privacy. Despite its luxury status, St. Barts retains a relaxed vibe, where even the most high-profile visitors can feel at ease.
The accommodation styles in both islands reflect their unique characteristics. Aruba’s resorts often feature colorful Dutch colonial architecture and offer views of both the beach and the island’s interior. In St. Barts, accommodations tend to be luxurious and intimate, with traditional Caribbean villas perched on the hills, boasting panoramic views of the sea and surrounding greenery.
It’s worth noting the commitment to sustainability in both destinations. Aruba aims to become fully sustainable by 2020, with many hotels participating in eco-friendly initiatives. Similarly, St. Barts’ hotels are committed to preserving the island’s natural beauty, adhering to strict building codes and implementing eco-friendly practices.
Dining and Cuisine: Gastronomic Journey
Aruba’s culinary scene is as diverse as its cultural heritage. The island’s food fuses influences from the Amerindians, Africa, and Europe, creating unique flavors. Dishes like Keshi Yena (stuffed cheese) and pastechi (Aruban pastry) are not to be missed. The island also hosts food festivals, such as the annual Aruba Wine, Food & Art Festival, that further enrich its culinary scene.
St. Barts’ cuisine is an exquisite combination of French culinary sophistication with a Caribbean twist. Fresh seafood and Creole dishes are common, and French pastries and wines are staples in daily life. St. Barts also hosts the annual Taste of St. Barth festival, where chefs from different parts of the world showcase their skills, providing a gastronomic delight.
Despite the differences, both islands emphasize fresh, local ingredients in their cuisine. Aruba’s restaurants often incorporate local produce and seafood, and the island’s Dutch cheese is a must-try. St. Barts’ culinary scene also prides itself on its use of local ingredients, with an emphasis on fresh seafood, locally grown fruits, and vegetables.
Both Aruba and St. Barts offer a range of dining experiences, from casual beachside shacks serving local dishes to high-end restaurants offering gourmet cuisine. In Aruba, you can enjoy a romantic dinner on the beach or a vibrant beach barbeque with traditional music. In St. Barts, you can dine at a gourmet restaurant overlooking a marina or enjoy a meal at a quaint, family-run eatery in the heart of Gustavia.
FAQ
Is St Barts worth the hype?
St Barts is undoubtedly worth the hype due to its exceptional combination of natural beauty, luxurious amenities, and exclusive atmosphere. With pristine white-sand beaches, crystal-clear turquoise waters, and a charming French-Caribbean ambiance, St Barts captivates visitors with its breathtaking scenery. The island’s upscale resorts, world-class dining options, high-end shopping, and vibrant nightlife further contribute to its allure, making it a coveted destination for discerning travelers seeking an opulent and unforgettable experience.
What is so great about St Barts?
St Barts is renowned for its unparalleled beauty, blending stunning tropical landscapes with chic sophistication. The island boasts a remarkable collection of picturesque beaches, including Colombier Beach and Saline Beach, offering pristine sands and idyllic seascapes. St Barts also captivates visitors with its charming capital, Gustavia, featuring quaint streets lined with designer boutiques, upscale restaurants, and luxury yachts, providing a unique blend of Caribbean charm and high-end elegance.
Why do billionaires go to St Barts?
St Barts has become a magnet for billionaires due to its exclusive allure and lavish offerings. The island provides a discreet and secure environment, appealing to those seeking privacy and seclusion. St Barts offers a wide array of luxury accommodations, extravagant villas, and high-end services, ensuring the utmost comfort and opulence. Additionally, its reputation as a playground for the rich and famous, coupled with its vibrant social scene, makes St Barts an irresistible destination for billionaires looking to indulge in a glamorous and elite experience.